Data to 20 November 2026
About

DossiersAnswer as of 20 Nov 2026

Are the products doing what they promise?

5 of 6 promises hold

Not holding: international ETFs, whose median premium to NAV is 48.92% against a bar of within ±0.50%.

Holding: balanced advantage funds (equity that moves against valuation), equity ETFs (tracking; price close to NAV), gold ETFs (price close to NAV) and small-cap funds (liquidity).

The evidence

Promises and tests

Each promise has one fixed test, set before today's values were looked at.

ProductPromiseMeasureTodayBarHolds?
Balanced advantage fundsHold more equity when shares are cheap, less when they are dearCorrelation of their net equity with the Nifty 50's P/E, last three years−0.51−0.30 or loweryes
Equity ETFsTrack their index closely and cheaplyMedian one-year tracking difference−0.26 ptsno worse than −0.50 pointsyes
Equity ETFsTrade close to the value of what they holdMedian premium to NAV−0.19%within ±0.50%yes
Gold ETFsTrade close to the value of what they holdMedian premium to NAV−0.44%within ±0.50%yes
International ETFsTrade close to the value of what they holdMedian premium to NAV48.92%within ±0.50%no
Small-cap fundsCan meet heavy redemptionsDays the median fund needs to sell a quarter of its portfolio3.0 days10 days or feweryes

Behind the answer

Balanced advantage funds hold an estimated 55% in unhedged equity, with the Nifty 50 at 21.0 times earnings

The promise is to hold more equity when shares are cheap and less when they are dear. Top: the funds' estimated net equity (AUM-weighted, from daily NAVs). Bottom: the Nifty 50's P/E. If the promise holds, the top line falls when the bottom one rises.

Net equity, % of assets40%60%80%55%Nifty 50 P/E20202022202420261020304021Net equity, % of assets40%60%80%55%Nifty 50 P/E20202022202420261020304021Net equity, % of assets40%60%80%55%Nifty 50 P/E20202022202420261020304021Net equity, % of assets30%40%50%60%70%80%55%Nifty 50 P/E20202022202420261020304021Net equity, % of assets30%40%50%60%70%80%55%Nifty 50 P/E201920202021202220232024202520261015202530354021

Source: AMFI daily NAV (all eras), AMFI quarterly scheme AUM; NSE Nifty 50 and Nifty 500 TRI; NSE 5-year G-sec index; disclosed portfolios for validation

Table
DateNet equityNifty 50 P/E
Nov 202655%21
Aug 202661%20
Jun 202661%20
Mar 202664%20
Dec 202556%23
Sept 202558%22
Jul 202553%23
Apr 202559%21
Jan 202546%21
Oct 202448%23
Aug 202453%23
May 202458%21
Feb 202450%23
Nov 202352%21
Sept 202345%22
Jun 202347%22
Mar 202347%20
Dec 202249%21
Sept 202248%21
Jul 202244%20
Apr 202244%23
Jan 202245%24
Oct 202146%26
Aug 202141%27
May 202151%30
Feb 202158%34
Nov 202066%30
Sept 202066%27
Jun 202064%20
Mar 202069%16
Dec 201971%24
Oct 201968%21
Jul 201963%24
Apr 201962%24
Jan 201955%22
Nov 201850%21
Aug 201841%23

Across 37 balanced advantage funds, estimated net equity runs from 2% to 70%

Each dot is one fund's estimated unhedged equity today. The same category label covers funds with very different exposure; the industry average hides it.

0%20%40%60%80%AUM-weightedUnifi Dynamic Asset Allocation Fund: 2%Parag Parikh Dynamic Asset Allocation Fund: 12%Samco Dynamic Asset Allocation Fund: 20%UTI - Unit Linked Insurance Plan: 34%HSBC Balanced Advantage Fund: 43%Mirae Asset Balanced Advantage Fund: 43%BANK OF INDIA BALANCED ADVANTAGE FUND: 43%NJ Balanced Advantage Fund: 44%The Wealth Company Balanced Advantage Fund: 44%Motilal Oswal Balanced Advantage Fund (MOFDYNAMIC): 44%LIC MF Balanced Advantage Fund: 45%ITI Balanced Advantage Fund: 46%BANDHAN Balanced Advantage Fund: 47%SBI Balanced Advantage Fund: 48%Franklin India Balanced Advantage Fund: 48%Union Balanced Advantage Fund: 49%WhiteOak Capital Balanced Advantage Fund: 50%Kotak Balanced Advantage Fund: 50%Edelweiss Balanced Advantage Fund: 51%Sundaram Dynamic Asset Allocation Fund: 54%Tata Balanced Advantage Fund: 54%Nippon India Balanced Advantage Fund: 54%Aditya Birla Sun Life Balanced Advantage Fund: 55%Helios Balanced Advantage Fund: 55%Mahindra Manulife Balanced Advantage Fund: 55%quant Dynamic Asset Allocation Fund: 57%DSP Dynamic Asset Allocation Fund: 57%Axis Balanced Advantage Fund: 57%Canara Robeco Balanced Advantage Fund: 60%ICICI Prudential Balanced Advantage Fund: 60%Shriram Balanced Advantage Fund: 60%HDFC Balanced Advantage Fund: 60%Baroda BNP Paribas Balanced Advantage Fund: 62%Invesco India Balanced Advantage Fund: 62%PGIM India Balanced Advantage Fund: 67%UTI Balanced Advantage Fund: 67%Bajaj Finserv Balanced Advantage Fund: 70%0%20%40%60%80%AUM-weightedUnifi Dynamic Asset Allocation Fund: 2%Parag Parikh Dynamic Asset Allocation Fund: 12%Samco Dynamic Asset Allocation Fund: 20%UTI - Unit Linked Insurance Plan: 34%HSBC Balanced Advantage Fund: 43%Mirae Asset Balanced Advantage Fund: 43%BANK OF INDIA BALANCED ADVANTAGE FUND: 43%NJ Balanced Advantage Fund: 44%The Wealth Company Balanced Advantage Fund: 44%Motilal Oswal Balanced Advantage Fund (MOFDYNAMIC): 44%LIC MF Balanced Advantage Fund: 45%ITI Balanced Advantage Fund: 46%BANDHAN Balanced Advantage Fund: 47%SBI Balanced Advantage Fund: 48%Franklin India Balanced Advantage Fund: 48%Union Balanced Advantage Fund: 49%WhiteOak Capital Balanced Advantage Fund: 50%Kotak Balanced Advantage Fund: 50%Edelweiss Balanced Advantage Fund: 51%Sundaram Dynamic Asset Allocation Fund: 54%Tata Balanced Advantage Fund: 54%Nippon India Balanced Advantage Fund: 54%Aditya Birla Sun Life Balanced Advantage Fund: 55%Helios Balanced Advantage Fund: 55%Mahindra Manulife Balanced Advantage Fund: 55%quant Dynamic Asset Allocation Fund: 57%DSP Dynamic Asset Allocation Fund: 57%Axis Balanced Advantage Fund: 57%Canara Robeco Balanced Advantage Fund: 60%ICICI Prudential Balanced Advantage Fund: 60%Shriram Balanced Advantage Fund: 60%HDFC Balanced Advantage Fund: 60%Baroda BNP Paribas Balanced Advantage Fund: 62%Invesco India Balanced Advantage Fund: 62%PGIM India Balanced Advantage Fund: 67%UTI Balanced Advantage Fund: 67%Bajaj Finserv Balanced Advantage Fund: 70%0%20%40%60%80%AUM-weightedUnifi Dynamic Asset Allocation Fund: 2%Parag Parikh Dynamic Asset Allocation Fund: 12%Samco Dynamic Asset Allocation Fund: 20%UTI - Unit Linked Insurance Plan: 34%HSBC Balanced Advantage Fund: 43%Mirae Asset Balanced Advantage Fund: 43%BANK OF INDIA BALANCED ADVANTAGE FUND: 43%NJ Balanced Advantage Fund: 44%The Wealth Company Balanced Advantage Fund: 44%Motilal Oswal Balanced Advantage Fund (MOFDYNAMIC): 44%LIC MF Balanced Advantage Fund: 45%ITI Balanced Advantage Fund: 46%BANDHAN Balanced Advantage Fund: 47%SBI Balanced Advantage Fund: 48%Franklin India Balanced Advantage Fund: 48%Union Balanced Advantage Fund: 49%WhiteOak Capital Balanced Advantage Fund: 50%Kotak Balanced Advantage Fund: 50%Edelweiss Balanced Advantage Fund: 51%Sundaram Dynamic Asset Allocation Fund: 54%Tata Balanced Advantage Fund: 54%Nippon India Balanced Advantage Fund: 54%Aditya Birla Sun Life Balanced Advantage Fund: 55%Helios Balanced Advantage Fund: 55%Mahindra Manulife Balanced Advantage Fund: 55%quant Dynamic Asset Allocation Fund: 57%DSP Dynamic Asset Allocation Fund: 57%Axis Balanced Advantage Fund: 57%Canara Robeco Balanced Advantage Fund: 60%ICICI Prudential Balanced Advantage Fund: 60%Shriram Balanced Advantage Fund: 60%HDFC Balanced Advantage Fund: 60%Baroda BNP Paribas Balanced Advantage Fund: 62%Invesco India Balanced Advantage Fund: 62%PGIM India Balanced Advantage Fund: 67%UTI Balanced Advantage Fund: 67%Bajaj Finserv Balanced Advantage Fund: 70%0%10%20%30%40%50%60%70%80%AUM-weightedUnifi Dynamic Asset Allocation Fund: 2%Parag Parikh Dynamic Asset Allocation Fund: 12%Samco Dynamic Asset Allocation Fund: 20%UTI - Unit Linked Insurance Plan: 34%HSBC Balanced Advantage Fund: 43%Mirae Asset Balanced Advantage Fund: 43%BANK OF INDIA BALANCED ADVANTAGE FUND: 43%NJ Balanced Advantage Fund: 44%The Wealth Company Balanced Advantage Fund: 44%Motilal Oswal Balanced Advantage Fund (MOFDYNAMIC): 44%LIC MF Balanced Advantage Fund: 45%ITI Balanced Advantage Fund: 46%BANDHAN Balanced Advantage Fund: 47%SBI Balanced Advantage Fund: 48%Franklin India Balanced Advantage Fund: 48%Union Balanced Advantage Fund: 49%WhiteOak Capital Balanced Advantage Fund: 50%Kotak Balanced Advantage Fund: 50%Edelweiss Balanced Advantage Fund: 51%Sundaram Dynamic Asset Allocation Fund: 54%Tata Balanced Advantage Fund: 54%Nippon India Balanced Advantage Fund: 54%Aditya Birla Sun Life Balanced Advantage Fund: 55%Helios Balanced Advantage Fund: 55%Mahindra Manulife Balanced Advantage Fund: 55%quant Dynamic Asset Allocation Fund: 57%DSP Dynamic Asset Allocation Fund: 57%Axis Balanced Advantage Fund: 57%Canara Robeco Balanced Advantage Fund: 60%ICICI Prudential Balanced Advantage Fund: 60%Shriram Balanced Advantage Fund: 60%HDFC Balanced Advantage Fund: 60%Baroda BNP Paribas Balanced Advantage Fund: 62%Invesco India Balanced Advantage Fund: 62%PGIM India Balanced Advantage Fund: 67%UTI Balanced Advantage Fund: 67%Bajaj Finserv Balanced Advantage Fund: 70%0%10%20%30%40%50%60%70%80%AUM-weightedUnifi Dynamic Asset Allocation Fund: 2%Parag Parikh Dynamic Asset Allocation Fund: 12%Samco Dynamic Asset Allocation Fund: 20%UTI - Unit Linked Insurance Plan: 34%HSBC Balanced Advantage Fund: 43%Mirae Asset Balanced Advantage Fund: 43%BANK OF INDIA BALANCED ADVANTAGE FUND: 43%NJ Balanced Advantage Fund: 44%The Wealth Company Balanced Advantage Fund: 44%Motilal Oswal Balanced Advantage Fund (MOFDYNAMIC): 44%LIC MF Balanced Advantage Fund: 45%ITI Balanced Advantage Fund: 46%BANDHAN Balanced Advantage Fund: 47%SBI Balanced Advantage Fund: 48%Franklin India Balanced Advantage Fund: 48%Union Balanced Advantage Fund: 49%WhiteOak Capital Balanced Advantage Fund: 50%Kotak Balanced Advantage Fund: 50%Edelweiss Balanced Advantage Fund: 51%Sundaram Dynamic Asset Allocation Fund: 54%Tata Balanced Advantage Fund: 54%Nippon India Balanced Advantage Fund: 54%Aditya Birla Sun Life Balanced Advantage Fund: 55%Helios Balanced Advantage Fund: 55%Mahindra Manulife Balanced Advantage Fund: 55%quant Dynamic Asset Allocation Fund: 57%DSP Dynamic Asset Allocation Fund: 57%Axis Balanced Advantage Fund: 57%Canara Robeco Balanced Advantage Fund: 60%ICICI Prudential Balanced Advantage Fund: 60%Shriram Balanced Advantage Fund: 60%HDFC Balanced Advantage Fund: 60%Baroda BNP Paribas Balanced Advantage Fund: 62%Invesco India Balanced Advantage Fund: 62%PGIM India Balanced Advantage Fund: 67%UTI Balanced Advantage Fund: 67%Bajaj Finserv Balanced Advantage Fund: 70%

Source: AMFI daily NAV (all eras), AMFI quarterly scheme AUM; NSE Nifty 50 and Nifty 500 TRI; NSE 5-year G-sec index; disclosed portfolios for validation

Table
Value
HDFC Balanced Advantage Fund60%
ICICI Prudential Balanced Advantage Fund60%
SBI Balanced Advantage Fund48%
Kotak Balanced Advantage Fund50%
Edelweiss Balanced Advantage Fund51%
Aditya Birla Sun Life Balanced Advantage Fund55%
Nippon India Balanced Advantage Fund54%
Tata Balanced Advantage Fund54%
Baroda BNP Paribas Balanced Advantage Fund62%
UTI - Unit Linked Insurance Plan34%
Axis Balanced Advantage Fund57%
DSP Dynamic Asset Allocation Fund57%
NJ Balanced Advantage Fund44%
UTI Balanced Advantage Fund67%
Franklin India Balanced Advantage Fund48%
Parag Parikh Dynamic Asset Allocation Fund12%
WhiteOak Capital Balanced Advantage Fund50%
BANDHAN Balanced Advantage Fund47%
Mirae Asset Balanced Advantage Fund43%
Sundaram Dynamic Asset Allocation Fund54%
HSBC Balanced Advantage Fund43%
Unifi Dynamic Asset Allocation Fund2%
Bajaj Finserv Balanced Advantage Fund70%
Union Balanced Advantage Fund49%
Canara Robeco Balanced Advantage Fund60%
Invesco India Balanced Advantage Fund62%
Mahindra Manulife Balanced Advantage Fund55%
quant Dynamic Asset Allocation Fund57%
PGIM India Balanced Advantage Fund67%
Motilal Oswal Balanced Advantage Fund (MOFDYNAMIC)44%
LIC MF Balanced Advantage Fund45%
ITI Balanced Advantage Fund46%
Helios Balanced Advantage Fund55%
BANK OF INDIA BALANCED ADVANTAGE FUND43%
Samco Dynamic Asset Allocation Fund20%
The Wealth Company Balanced Advantage Fund44%
Shriram Balanced Advantage Fund60%

Median premium to NAV: equity ETFs −0.19%, gold ETFs −0.44%, international ETFs 48.92%

What the median ETF in each category costs on the exchange against the value of what it holds, each session since 2020. The band is ±0.5%, the test this page uses. International ETFs trade far above it because the regulator caps how much funds may invest abroad, so new units cannot be created to meet demand.

Equity ETFs−5%0.0%5%10%−0.2%Gold ETFs−10%−5%0.0%5%10%−0.4%International ETFs2020202220242026−20%0.0%20%40%60%49%Equity ETFs−5%0.0%5%10%−0.2%Gold ETFs−10%−5%0.0%5%10%−0.4%International ETFs2020202220242026−20%0.0%20%40%60%49%Equity ETFs−5%0.0%5%10%−0.2%Gold ETFs−10%−5%0.0%5%10%−0.4%International ETFs2020202220242026−20%0.0%20%40%60%49%Equity ETFs−5%0.0%5%10%−0.2%Gold ETFs−10%−5%0.0%5%10%−0.4%International ETFs2020202220242026−20%0.0%20%40%60%49%Equity ETFs−2%0.0%2%4%6%8%10%−0.2%Gold ETFs−10%−5%0.0%5%10%−0.4%International ETFs2020202120222023202420252026−20%0.0%20%40%60%49%

Source: NSE capital-market bhavcopy (closes, traded value); AMFI NAV history, TER, quarterly AUM and tracking-difference disclosures; NSE total-return indices; corporate actions (ETF distributions and splits)

Table
DateEquity ETFsGold ETFsInternational ETFs
Nov 2026−0.2%−0.4%49%
Sept 20260.1%0.1%23%
Jul 2026−0.1%−0.1%23%
May 20260.1%−0.5%21%
Mar 20260.1%0.3%17%
Jan 20260.0%0.4%16%
Nov 20250.1%0.1%21%
Sept 20250.1%0.2%8%
Jun 2025−0.1%0.1%6%
Apr 2025−0.0%0.2%11%
Feb 20250.1%0.2%18%
Dec 20240.3%0.0%14%
Oct 20240.2%0.0%−0.5%
Aug 2024−0.0%0.1%1.0%
Jun 2024−0.0%0.4%4%
Apr 2024−0.0%0.1%3%
Feb 20240.1%0.3%−0.7%
Dec 20230.0%0.2%1.5%
Oct 20230.1%1.0%3%
Jul 20230.0%−0.1%−0.6%
May 2023−0.0%−0.2%0.8%
Mar 20230.1%−1.3%−0.4%
Jan 2023−0.0%−1.4%0.9%
Nov 20220.0%−1.0%0.9%
Sept 20220.1%0.2%2%
Jul 20220.2%−1.3%1.0%
May 20220.3%0.1%1.1%
Mar 20220.2%−4%1.4%
Jan 2022−0.1%−0.6%3%
Nov 20210.1%0.3%1.1%
Aug 2021−0.3%−0.1%1.6%
Jun 20210.1%−0.3%0.4%
Apr 2021−0.2%0.2%2%
Feb 20210.2%0.1%−0.1%
Dec 20200.0%0.2%2%
Oct 2020−0.1%0.0%1.8%
Aug 2020−0.0%−0.4%6%
Jun 20200.2%0.0%8%
Apr 20201.0%6%5%
Feb 2020−0.0%−0.3%9%

The median small-cap fund says it needs 3.0 days to sell a quarter of its portfolio; the median mid-cap fund 2.0

From the regulator's monthly stress test disclosure (from 2024): days each fund would need to sell 25% of its portfolio without moving prices much. More days means a fund would struggle to meet heavy redemptions.

Small-cap fundsMid-cap funds

20252026012345322025202601234532202520260123453220252026012345322025202601234532

Source: AMFI, Disclosure of risk parameters for mid-cap and small-cap schemes (monthly)

Table
DateSmall-cap fundsMid-cap funds
Oct 202632
Sept 202632
Aug 202632
Jul 202632
Jun 202632
May 202632
Apr 202632
Mar 202632
Feb 202642
Jan 202642
Dec 202532
Nov 202532
Oct 202543
Sept 202532
Aug 202532
Jul 202542
Jun 202542
May 202542
Apr 202532
Mar 202542
Feb 202542
Jan 202542
Dec 202442
Nov 202442
Oct 202442
Sept 202432
Aug 202432
Jul 202432
Jun 202432
May 202442
Apr 202432
Mar 202432
Feb 202432

What history says

Balanced advantage funds and valuation

Descriptive, not a test

My estimate of these funds' net equity comes from their daily NAVs, checked against arbitrage funds, which should read near zero. The funds page shows each fund's estimate against what it disclosed.

Balanced advantage funds' real equity

Products and later returns

Not tested

These tests ask whether a product does what it says, not whether it will make money.

What would change the answer

Balanced advantage funds
Correlation of their net equity with the Nifty 50's P/E, last three years: −0.51; the bar is −0.30 or lower.
Equity ETFs
Median one-year tracking difference: −0.26 pts; the bar is no worse than −0.50 points.
Equity ETFs
Median premium to NAV: −0.19%; the bar is within ±0.50%.
Gold ETFs
Median premium to NAV: −0.44%; the bar is within ±0.50%.
International ETFs
Median premium to NAV: 48.92%; the bar is within ±0.50%.
Small-cap funds
Days the median fund needs to sell a quarter of its portfolio: 3.0 days; the bar is 10 days or fewer.

The readings and the dashboards

the usual range: the middle half of all readingstodayEach line runs from the lowest reading ever to the highest.

How these answers are made: the dossier method. Historical research, not investment advice.