The Nifty 50 trades at 21.0 times trailing earnings, higher than 72% of readings since 1999. Its CAPE, price over ten years of inflation-adjusted earnings, is 28.7. Mid caps are dearer than usual against it on book value, not on earnings. History says dear starts have tended to be followed by lower returns, but too loosely and over too few decades to forecast from.
Written for long-term investors and anyone deciding how much to keep in equities. Data to 20 Nov 2026.
Inside its usual range of 14.9 to 21.4. The record is 34.9, in February 2021. Down from 22.8 a year ago.
What it is. What investors pay for each rupee of the Nifty 50's profits over the last year.
How to read it. A high P/E means investors expect profits to grow, or are simply paying up. It says little about next month. It tells you what you are paying, not what happens next.
Each index is placed only against its own past: a P/E percentile of 90 means it has been cheaper 90% of the time. Sectors earn in different ways, so one index's P/E is never compared with another's.
9 of 22 indices trade at a P/E above the middle of their own history; 18 at a P/B above it
Percentile of today's reading among all of that index's own readings: 100 is its dearest ever, 0 its cheapest. Nifty Smallcap 100 is dearest against its past on P/E (89), Nifty LargeMidcap 250 cheapest (18).
How to read it. Read along each row: the further right, the dearer that index against its own past. Where P/B sits well right of P/E, the index earns more on its book than it used to, so a high P/B costs less in earnings terms. NSE's P/B steps down on 29 September 2023 with prices flat (the Nifty 50's by a factor of 1.25), so earlier book values are rescaled to match.
9 of 22 indices trade at a P/E above the middle of their own history; 18 at a P/B above it. Dot plot of 22 items. P/E percentile: highest Nifty Smallcap 100 at 89, lowest Nifty LargeMidcap 250 at 18.
Source: NSE Indices (P/E and P/B), tipsheet calculation
As of 20 Nov 2026. Click a column to sort. CAPE and its percentile are blank where the 2021 earnings switch can't be bridged or the index has under five years of CAPE.
As of 20 Nov 2026. Click a column to sort. CAPE and its percentile are blank where the 2021 earnings switch can't be bridged or the index has under five years of CAPE.
Index
P/E
P/E percentile
P/B
P/B percentile
CAPE
CAPE percentile
Div. yield
Yield percentile
More
Nifty 50
21.0
72
3.17
67
28.7
82
1.02%
7
Nifty 500
22.5
69
3.37
77
33.5
84
0.89%
2
Nifty Next 50
17.8
33
3.52
80
37.8
72
0.94%
25
Nifty IT
19.0
38
5.45
45
24.5
39
1.69%
48
Nifty FMCG
34.1
54
8.06
26
40.0
22
0.98%
5
Nifty Bank
14.3
43
1.95
20
27.1
64
0.66%
22
Nifty Energy
13.4
54
2.04
68
17.3
59
1.17%
11
Nifty Pharma
45.7
89
5.35
78
57.0
97
0.60%
20
Nifty Midcap 100
27.8
41
3.94
84
–
–
0.62%
10
Nifty 100
20.4
54
3.22
63
30.0
70
1.00%
5
Nifty Infrastructure
22.4
70
2.88
80
–
–
0.79%
12
Nifty PSU Bank
8.5
45
1.37
77
16.6
99
0.74%
33
Nifty Realty
39.4
21
4.10
83
–
–
0.47%
48
Nifty Smallcap 100
34.5
89
3.77
85
–
–
0.60%
1
Nifty Auto
31.4
58
4.50
56
–
–
1.06%
59
Nifty Metal
14.5
34
2.61
88
–
–
1.19%
23
Nifty 200
21.5
44
3.34
69
31.8
51
0.93%
2
Nifty Financial Services
17.0
46
2.67
32
27.4
35
0.95%
48
Nifty Smallcap 250
32.1
48
3.43
72
50.1
–
0.60%
16
Nifty Midcap 150
28.2
41
3.99
71
–
–
0.65%
29
Nifty MidSmallcap 400
29.5
43
3.77
72
–
–
0.64%
24
Nifty LargeMidcap 250
23.5
18
3.55
59
–
–
0.82%
12
Are mid and small caps dear against large caps?
Set each size index's valuation against the Nifty 50's and the question becomes relative: how much more is the market paying for smaller companies than usual? On book value the answer is a lot. Mid caps trade at 1.29× the Nifty 50's P/B, against a median of 0.87× since 2005; on earnings the premium is ordinary.
Mid caps' P/B over the Nifty 50's is higher than in 93% of months since 2005; small caps' is at its 99th percentile
Month-end P/B of each index divided by the Nifty 50's. Midcap 100 from Jul 2005, Smallcap 100 from Mar 2011, Next 50 from Jan 1999.
How to read it. Above 1, the index costs more per rupee of book value than the Nifty 50. Mid caps were cheapest against large caps in Feb 2009 (0.63×), after the 2008 crash, and have been above 1 since Jan 2024. Book values on both sides are on one basis across NSE's 2023 P/B break.
Midcap 100Smallcap 100Next 50
Loading chart…
Source: NSE Indices published P/E and P/B, tipsheet calculation.
On earnings, mid caps' premium sits near the middle of its range since 2021; small caps' is near its top
Month-end P/E of each index divided by the Nifty 50's, from Mar 2021, the first month every index is on consolidated earnings. Before then NSE's switch can't be bridged for the Midcap 100, so no longer comparison is honest.
How to read it. Mid caps' P/E is 1.34× the Nifty 50's (the 54th percentile of 68 months); small caps' is 1.75× (96th); the Next 50's is 0.89× (9th).
Midcap 100Smallcap 100Next 50
Loading chart…
Source: NSE Indices published P/E and P/B, tipsheet calculation.
The two measures disagree because mid caps now earn more on their book than they used to. P/B divided by P/E is earnings per rupee of book value. Against the Nifty 50, mid caps earned 0.67× as much per rupee of book in Mar 2021 and 0.96× as much in Oct 2026. Paying a record premium for their book buys more earnings than it did. Small caps are dear on both counts.
Has a dear mid-cap market been followed by mid caps lagging? In the sample, yes, loosely: over three years, a relative P/B 10% higher went with mid caps trailing the Nifty 50 by about 1.7 points a year more. But about 45% of that slope is what a slow-moving measure produces by chance in a sample of 7.1 independent three-year periods. The bootstrap p is 0.14, and out of sample the fitted line forecast worse than simply assuming the average gap (R² of −3%). The test was written down before it was run (C20) and does not pass.
Each row fits the yearly return gap (index minus Nifty 50, total return, log) over the horizon to the relative P/B a month before the start. Effect: points a year for a relative P/B 10% higher. Chance: the part of that effect a persistent measure produces with no real link (10,000 simulations). Only Midcap 100 at three years was tested; the rest are reported. NSE's Smallcap 100 P/B has two gaps of several months, which end its sample in 2016, so only rows with at least three independent periods are shown.
Each row fits the yearly return gap (index minus Nifty 50, total return, log) over the horizon to the relative P/B a month before the start. Effect: points a year for a relative P/B 10% higher. Chance: the part of that effect a persistent measure produces with no real link (10,000 simulations). Only Midcap 100 at three years was tested; the rest are reported. NSE's Smallcap 100 P/B has two gaps of several months, which end its sample in 2016, so only rows with at least three independent periods are shown.
Index
Horizon
Independent periods
Effect, pts a year
Effect beyond chance
Bootstrap p
Out-of-sample R², %
…on independent periods
Starts from
More
Nifty Midcap 100
1 year
21.2
−1.8
−0.6
0.27
−29
15.2
2005-08
Nifty Midcap 100
3 years
7.1
−1.7
−1.0
0.14
−3
4.4
2005-08
Nifty Midcap 100
5 years
4.2
−0.6
0.0
0.52
−14
2.2
2005-08
Nifty Smallcap 100
1 year
5.1
−4.1
−0.5
0.44
–
–
2011-04
Nifty Next 50
1 year
23.8
−1.8
−1.4
0.11
−62
17.8
2003-01
Nifty Next 50
3 years
7.9
−0.7
−0.4
0.34
−41
5.3
2003-01
Nifty Next 50
5 years
4.8
−0.3
−0.1
0.47
−14
2.8
2003-01
Are sectors unusually far apart?
Each month, place ten sector indices against their own P/B history as it stood then, and measure how spread out they are: the gap between the dearest quarter and the cheapest quarter of sectors. Today that gap is 29 percentile points, against a median of 35 since 2010, so sectors are about as far apart as usual.
The spread of sector valuations is higher than in 35% of months since 2010
Interquartile range of the ten sectors' P/B percentiles, each within its own history to that month (at least three years of it). Bank, IT, FMCG, Pharma, Energy, Metal, Auto, Realty, Infrastructure and PSU Bank; from Jul 2010, when six of them had three years of history.
How to read it. High means some sectors sit near their dearest and others near their cheapest; low means they move together. The widest spread was in Jul 2015, the narrowest in Oct 2020, when most sectors sat in the cheaper half of their own history after the Covid crash.
Spread across sectorsIts median to date
Loading chart…
Source: NSE Indices published P/B, tipsheet calculation.
Buying the cheapest third of sectors and avoiding the dearest earned 2.0 points over the next year on average, too little to tell from chance
Every month from Jul 2010 to Oct 2025: the twelve-month total return of the cheapest third of sectors (by P/B percentile within their own history, as known then) minus the dearest third, equal-weighted, from the next session's close.
How to read it. Bars above zero are years the cheap sectors won. Neighbouring bars share eleven of their twelve months, so the 184 bars hold only about 16 independent years; do not count bars. Taking one start a year so that no two windows overlap, the cheap third won in 40% to 69% of years (15 or more each), depending on the calendar month chosen, by −2.7 to 4.9 points on average.
Buying the cheapest third of sectors and avoiding the dearest earned 2.0 points over the next year on average, too little to tell from chance. Bar chart, Jul 2010 to Oct 2025. Cheapest third minus dearest third, next 12 months: latest −0 pts, range −50 pts to +42 pts.
Source: NSE Indices (P/B, total return), tipsheet calculation
Shuffling the sectors' valuations at random within each month gives a spread this large 8% of the time (the Newey-West t is 0.6). The test was written down before it was run (C21) and does not pass. In months when sectors were more spread out than their median to date, the cheap third beat the dear third by 5.3 points on average, against 0.2 otherwise. Those 66 overlapping months amount to at most about 6 independent years, so the split was reported, not tested, and is no more than a lead.
Over time
P/E moves with both prices and profits, so it can jump when profits collapse, as in 2020–21, as much as when prices soar. CAPE averages ten years of real earnings and moves more slowly. Choose an index to see its own history.
Nifty 50: trailing P/E
Weekly. Before March 2021 NSE used standalone earnings; the consolidated-basis line rescales that history.
How to read it. Follow the coloured line. Where the grey line sits above it before 2021, NSE's published figure was on standalone earnings and overstated the P/E.
P/E (consolidated basis)P/E as NSE published it
Loading chart…
Source: NSE Indices published PE, PB and dividend yield; CPI from IndiaDataHub (MoSPI, spliced).
Weekly. NSE's P/B steps down on 29 September 2023 with prices flat; the coloured line rescales earlier book values to match.
How to read it. Follow the coloured line. Where the grey line sits above it before late 2023, NSE's earlier book values were on a smaller basis and overstated the P/B.
P/B (one basis)P/B as NSE published it
Loading chart…
Source: NSE Indices published PE, PB and dividend yield; CPI from IndiaDataHub (MoSPI, spliced).
An index can rise because its implied earnings grew, investors paid a higher P/E, or dividends were reinvested. This accounting separates those three movements. Changes in index membership and earnings definitions can also move implied earnings, so this is not a measure of organic profit growth.
Over the long run, earnings did the work: since 1999 the Nifty 50's P/E added 1.3 points a year of its 12.6
Each index's whole history to 20 Nov 2026, annualised, in log-return points a year, on the consolidated-earnings basis. Only indices with at least 15 years whose 2021 switch can be bridged. Each starts at its first reading: Nifty 500, Nifty IT, Nifty 50, Nifty FMCG in 1999; Nifty Next 50 in 2002; Nifty Bank in 2003; Nifty Pharma, Nifty Energy, Nifty 100 in 2005; Nifty PSU Bank in 2007; Nifty Financial Services, Nifty 200 in 2011.
How to read it. For 11 of 12 indices the P/E term is less than half the earnings term. Where it is large, check the start: the Nifty Bank began in 2003 at a P/E of 5.5, close to its lowest reading ever. The 2021 switch assumes the standalone-to-consolidated gap was constant; on NSE's raw figures the Nifty 50's P/E term is 0.6 points a year instead.
Over the long run, earnings did the work: since 1999 the Nifty 50's P/E added 1.3 points a year of its 12.6. Bar chart of 12 items. Implied earnings: highest Nifty IT at 17.0, lowest Nifty PSU Bank at 4.4.
Source: NSE Indices (P/E, total return), tipsheet calculation
Earnings have kept pace with the economy, but not decade by decade
Both rebased to 100 in March 2000. Earnings per share at the end of each financial year, on the consolidated basis with NSE's 2021 switch bridged; GDP compounded from MoSPI's yearly nominal growth. Log scale.
How to read it. From FY00 to FY26 Nifty 50 earnings grew 11.0% a year and nominal GDP 11.7%. Over long stretches profits cannot outgrow the economy for ever, and here they have not. In between they swing far apart: earnings grew 17.7% a year to 2008, 5.6% a year in the twelve years to 2020, and 13.4% a year since, against 10.0% for GDP.
Nifty 50 earnings per shareNominal GDP
Loading chart…
Source: NSE Indices (Nifty 50 P/E and close); MoSPI (nominal GDP)
A year's EPS growth fell short of nominal GDP growth in 17 of 26 years. Index earnings also move when members change, so this is not one fixed set of companies.
A year's EPS growth fell short of nominal GDP growth in 17 of 26 years. Index earnings also move when members change, so this is not one fixed set of companies.
Financial years
EPS growth, a year
Nominal GDP, a year
Gap, points
More
FY00 to FY08
17.7%
11.9%
5.8
FY08 to FY20
5.6%
12.5%
−6.8
FY20 to FY26
13.4%
10.0%
3.5
Nifty 50: one-year return contributions
Monthly readings of trailing calendar-year changes. Current month may be partial.
How to read it. The three components add to total log return. A negative P/E contribution means investors paid less for each unit of implied earnings. The gap around 2021 withholds windows crossing NSE's earnings-method change.
Over the last year, a change in the P/E moved 8 of 22 indices more than their earnings did
Each index's one-year total log return split into its three parts, in log-return points; sorted by the total.
How to read it. A bar mostly in the P/E colour is a year of investors paying more or less for the same earnings; one mostly in the earnings colour is a year of profits doing the work.
Over the last year, a change in the P/E moved 8 of 22 indices more than their earnings did. Bar chart of 22 items. Implied earnings: highest Nifty Metal at 41.5, lowest Nifty Pharma at −8.4.
Source: NSE Indices (P/E, dividend yield, total return), tipsheet calculation
Cumulative log-return points over each index's latest five-year window (not annualised), from 18 Nov 2021, when 10 of 22 indices had a P/E in the top quarter of their own history.
How to read it. Over five years, earnings moved 20 of 22 indices more than the change in their P/E did. A large P/E bar means the index ends the window much dearer or cheaper than it began.
The same split over five years. Bar chart of 22 items. Implied earnings: highest Nifty Auto at 163, lowest Nifty Metal at 2.
One-, three- and five-year windows for every index: cumulative contributions over the full window, not annualised, as 100 × log changes. Rounding may leave a 0.1-point difference in the displayed sum. Windows crossing 31 March 2021 are withheld.
One-, three- and five-year windows for every index: cumulative contributions over the full window, not annualised, as 100 × log changes. Rounding may leave a 0.1-point difference in the displayed sum. Windows crossing 31 March 2021 are withheld.
Index
Window
Implied earnings
P/E change
Reinvestment
Total log return
Ordinary return, %
From
To
More
Nifty 100
1 year
9.0
−9.4
1.0
0.7
0.7%
2025-11-20
2026-11-20
Nifty 100
3 years
35.2
−5.1
3.2
33.3
39.6%
2023-11-20
2026-11-20
Nifty 100
5 years
57.6
−18.7
5.5
44.5
56.1%
2021-11-18
2026-11-20
Nifty 200
1 year
10.4
−10.4
0.9
0.9
1.0%
2025-11-20
2026-11-20
Nifty 200
3 years
32.2
−0.6
3.0
34.6
41.3%
2023-11-20
2026-11-20
Nifty 200
5 years
59.1
−15.7
5.2
48.6
62.6%
2021-11-18
2026-11-20
Nifty 50
1 year
6.6
−8.1
1.0
−0.5
−0.5%
2025-11-20
2026-11-20
Nifty 50
3 years
27.2
−0.2
3.4
30.4
35.6%
2023-11-20
2026-11-20
Nifty 50
5 years
52.7
−15.4
5.8
43.2
54.0%
2021-11-18
2026-11-20
Nifty 500
1 year
9.0
−8.5
0.9
1.4
1.4%
2025-11-20
2026-11-20
Nifty 500
3 years
30.1
1.5
2.8
34.4
41.0%
2023-11-20
2026-11-20
Nifty 500
5 years
59.0
−13.6
5.0
50.3
65.4%
2021-11-18
2026-11-20
Nifty Auto
1 year
−0.5
4.9
1.1
5.4
5.6%
2025-11-20
2026-11-20
Nifty Auto
3 years
25.3
28.7
2.7
56.7
76.3%
2023-11-20
2026-11-20
Nifty Auto
5 years
162.6
−73.0
4.6
94.2
156.6%
2021-11-18
2026-11-20
Nifty Bank
1 year
23.4
−14.9
0.7
9.2
9.6%
2025-11-20
2026-11-20
Nifty Bank
3 years
43.9
−4.4
2.3
41.7
51.8%
2023-11-20
2026-11-20
Nifty Bank
5 years
102.8
−49.6
4.0
57.2
77.1%
2021-11-18
2026-11-20
Nifty Energy
1 year
17.3
−14.3
1.2
4.1
4.2%
2025-11-20
2026-11-20
Nifty Energy
3 years
−2.9
30.6
3.9
31.6
37.1%
2023-11-20
2026-11-20
Nifty Energy
5 years
27.9
17.1
7.5
52.6
69.1%
2021-11-18
2026-11-20
Nifty Financial Services
1 year
10.3
−6.8
0.9
4.5
4.6%
2025-11-20
2026-11-20
Nifty Financial Services
3 years
38.6
0.5
2.9
42.1
52.3%
2023-11-20
2026-11-20
Nifty Financial Services
5 years
80.5
−36.6
4.8
48.7
62.7%
2021-11-18
2026-11-20
Nifty FMCG
1 year
4.2
−17.5
1.0
−12.3
−11.6%
2025-11-20
2026-11-20
Nifty FMCG
3 years
14.8
−22.8
4.8
−3.2
−3.1%
2023-11-20
2026-11-20
Nifty FMCG
5 years
41.6
−19.3
8.3
30.5
35.6%
2021-11-18
2026-11-20
Nifty Infrastructure
1 year
−2.5
2.4
0.8
0.8
0.8%
2025-11-20
2026-11-20
Nifty Infrastructure
3 years
13.6
27.6
2.5
43.6
54.7%
2023-11-20
2026-11-20
Nifty Infrastructure
5 years
43.2
19.5
4.8
67.5
96.4%
2021-11-18
2026-11-20
Nifty IT
1 year
15.3
−32.0
1.7
−15.1
−14.0%
2025-11-20
2026-11-20
Nifty IT
3 years
32.6
−35.9
6.0
2.7
2.7%
2023-11-20
2026-11-20
Nifty IT
5 years
50.4
−64.4
9.9
−4.0
−3.9%
2021-11-18
2026-11-20
Nifty LargeMidcap 250
1 year
13.9
−13.2
0.8
1.5
1.6%
2025-11-20
2026-11-20
Nifty LargeMidcap 250
3 years
31.2
3.1
2.5
36.8
44.5%
2023-11-20
2026-11-20
Nifty LargeMidcap 250
5 years
68.4
−15.2
4.4
57.6
77.9%
2021-11-18
2026-11-20
Nifty Metal
1 year
41.5
−24.9
1.2
17.9
19.6%
2025-11-20
2026-11-20
Nifty Metal
3 years
131.4
−72.0
2.6
62.1
86.0%
2023-11-20
2026-11-20
Nifty Metal
5 years
2.3
79.3
6.3
87.9
140.9%
2021-11-18
2026-11-20
Nifty Midcap 100
1 year
20.5
−18.8
0.6
2.3
2.4%
2025-11-20
2026-11-20
Nifty Midcap 100
3 years
17.8
21.5
1.8
41.1
50.8%
2023-11-20
2026-11-20
Nifty Midcap 100
5 years
74.4
−5.9
3.5
71.9
105.3%
2021-11-18
2026-11-20
Nifty Midcap 150
1 year
18.6
−17.0
0.6
2.2
2.2%
2025-11-20
2026-11-20
Nifty Midcap 150
3 years
22.8
15.0
1.8
39.6
48.6%
2023-11-20
2026-11-20
Nifty Midcap 150
5 years
75.0
−8.8
3.4
69.6
100.5%
2021-11-18
2026-11-20
Nifty MidSmallcap 400
1 year
10.9
−8.2
0.6
3.3
3.3%
2025-11-20
2026-11-20
Nifty MidSmallcap 400
3 years
17.3
18.2
1.8
37.3
45.2%
2023-11-20
2026-11-20
Nifty MidSmallcap 400
5 years
68.3
−3.6
3.4
68.0
97.5%
2021-11-18
2026-11-20
Nifty Next 50
1 year
18.4
−13.3
0.9
6.0
6.2%
2025-11-20
2026-11-20
Nifty Next 50
3 years
69.2
−24.3
2.5
47.4
60.6%
2023-11-20
2026-11-20
Nifty Next 50
5 years
80.0
−28.2
4.3
56.1
75.3%
2021-11-18
2026-11-20
Nifty Pharma
1 year
−8.4
30.8
0.6
23.0
25.9%
2025-11-20
2026-11-20
Nifty Pharma
3 years
22.5
36.0
2.0
60.5
83.2%
2023-11-20
2026-11-20
Nifty Pharma
5 years
37.5
37.0
3.6
78.1
118.4%
2021-11-18
2026-11-20
Nifty PSU Bank
1 year
17.7
−2.7
0.7
15.8
17.1%
2025-11-20
2026-11-20
Nifty PSU Bank
3 years
49.6
17.1
2.1
68.8
99.1%
2023-11-20
2026-11-20
Nifty PSU Bank
5 years
152.5
−26.9
5.2
130.8
270.1%
2021-11-18
2026-11-20
Nifty Realty
1 year
9.1
−7.4
0.5
2.2
2.2%
2025-11-20
2026-11-20
Nifty Realty
3 years
42.2
−11.6
1.1
31.7
37.3%
2023-11-20
2026-11-20
Nifty Realty
5 years
109.0
−51.2
1.8
59.5
81.4%
2021-11-18
2026-11-20
Nifty Smallcap 100
1 year
1.5
5.8
0.6
7.9
8.3%
2025-11-20
2026-11-20
Nifty Smallcap 100
3 years
6.5
27.2
2.0
35.8
43.0%
2023-11-20
2026-11-20
Nifty Smallcap 100
5 years
44.4
12.2
3.8
60.4
83.0%
2021-11-18
2026-11-20
Nifty Smallcap 250
1 year
−3.5
8.4
0.6
5.5
5.7%
2025-11-20
2026-11-20
Nifty Smallcap 250
3 years
6.8
24.7
1.8
33.3
39.5%
2023-11-20
2026-11-20
Nifty Smallcap 250
5 years
54.5
6.9
3.5
65.0
91.5%
2021-11-18
2026-11-20
For example, an ordinary return of 10% is a log return of 9.5 points. To turn a sum back into an ordinary return, use 100 × (exp(sum ÷ 100) − 1). The table shows both.
Has valuation said anything about later returns?
At the Sensex CAPE of 27.5 in Oct 2026, the 2000–2021 relationship implies a real return of about 3.2% a year over the next five years, with an 80% range of −2.9% to 8.4%. That describes 5.3 independent five-year periods of history. It is not a forecast: none of the 12 tests of valuation against later returns passes.
Five five-year periods that don't overlap: in 7 of 10 pairs, the dearer start was followed by the lower real return
Starting Sensex CAPE against the Nifty 500's real return a year over the next five years, for start months exactly five years apart from the first, May 2000. Each dot is a period that shares no month with the others. Any such set holds only four or five points; this one starts from the first month, so the choice is not mine.
How to read it. Every start month could be plotted instead, 258 of them, but each shares 59 of its 60 months with the next. That cloud repeats these same few periods hundreds of times: it looks like a tight line (R² 0.69) and is not evidence of one.
Five five-year periods that don't overlap: in 7 of 10 pairs, the dearer start was followed by the lower real return. Scatter plot of 5 points: Real return a year over the five years against Sensex CAPE at the start.
Source: IIMA Indian Valuation Index (Sensex CAPE); NSE Indices (Nifty 500 TRI); all-India CPI
Pick different start months and the answer moves: a CAPE 10% higher went with anything from 4.2 points a year less to 1.8 more
The same fit on each of the 60 ways of choosing start months five years apart (4 to 5 periods each). The median is 2.7 points less; fitting all 258 overlapping months at once gives 3.0 points less.
How to read it. These are not independent estimates: neighbouring sets share four of their five periods. Their spread shows how much the answer depends on which months a study happens to start from, which a single fitted line hides.
Pick different start months and the answer moves: a CAPE 10% higher went with anything from 4.2 points a year less to 1.8 more. Histogram of 60 readings of Points a year for a CAPE 10% higher, from −4.2 to 1.8; median −2.7.
Source: IIMA Indian Valuation Index; NSE Indices; all-India CPI
A fair test has to allow for two traps. Overlapping windows make a few decades look like hundreds of observations. And a measure that moves slowly, as valuation does, produces a negative slope by chance in a short sample (the Stambaugh bias). The table below fits each measure to the Nifty 50's later real return, simulates 10,000 histories in which valuation tells you nothing, and checks each fit out of sample, using only windows that had closed at the time. On the Sensex CAPE at five years, a reading 10% higher went with 2.3 points a year less, of which 1.2 is what chance alone produces; the bootstrap p is 0.061 against a bar of 0.0042 for 12 tests. No measure passes at any horizon. CAPE's better showing out of sample (R² 39%) rests on 3.3 independent five-year periods of forecasts, which is why the figure for today is a description and not a forecast.
Nifty 50 real total return, annualised, against the valuation a month before the start. Effect: points a year for a reading 10% higher (dividend yield: per point of yield). Chance: the mean effect across 10,000 simulated histories with no link. A test passes only if its bootstrap p is below 0.05 ÷ 12, the effect beyond chance keeps its expected sign, and the out-of-sample R² is positive. Pre-registered as D1.
Nifty 50 real total return, annualised, against the valuation a month before the start. Effect: points a year for a reading 10% higher (dividend yield: per point of yield). Chance: the mean effect across 10,000 simulated histories with no link. A test passes only if its bootstrap p is below 0.05 ÷ 12, the effect beyond chance keeps its expected sign, and the out-of-sample R² is positive. Pre-registered as D1.
Measure
Horizon
Independent periods
Effect, pts a year
Of which chance
Bootstrap p
Out-of-sample R², %
…on independent periods
Result
More
Sensex CAPE (IIMA)
1 year
26.4
−2.6
−1.7
0.227
−6
20.5
Does not pass
Sensex CAPE (IIMA)
3 years
8.8
−2.3
−1.4
0.176
28
6.2
Does not pass
Sensex CAPE (IIMA)
5 years
5.3
−2.3
−1.2
0.061
39
3.3
Does not pass
Nifty 50 P/E
1 year
27.2
−3.2
−1.8
0.212
−25
21.2
Does not pass
Nifty 50 P/E
3 years
9.1
−1.7
−1.0
0.287
−142
6.4
Does not pass
Nifty 50 P/E
5 years
5.4
−1.3
−0.7
0.326
−128
3.5
Does not pass
Nifty 50 P/B
1 year
27.2
−4.4
−2.0
0.101
−1
21.2
Does not pass
Nifty 50 P/B
3 years
9.1
−2.8
−1.1
0.063
4
6.4
Does not pass
Nifty 50 P/B
5 years
5.4
−2.5
−0.9
0.029
−6
3.5
Does not pass
Nifty 50 dividend yield
1 year
26.2
18.7
2.6
0.059
2
20.3
Does not pass
Nifty 50 dividend yield
3 years
8.8
14.1
0.3
0.065
49
6.1
Does not pass
Nifty 50 dividend yield
5 years
5.2
4.7
−0.4
0.259
−21
3.3
Does not pass
Starts in the cheapest third of Sensex CAPE readings were followed by a median 12.8% a year; the dearest third by 2.3%
Median real return of the Nifty 500 over the next five years, by the third of Sensex CAPE readings the start fell in, with a 90% interval from a moving-block bootstrap. Each third holds about 1.4 independent periods.
How to read it. The thirds are cut on the whole sample, so this describes history and is not a rule anyone could have followed at the time. Wide intervals on so few periods are the honest picture.
Starts in the cheapest third of Sensex CAPE readings were followed by a median 12.8% a year; the dearest third by 2.3%. Estimates with intervals for 3 rows; 2 intervals are clear of 0.0%.
Source: IIMA Indian Valuation Index; NSE Indices; all-India CPI
Every signal in thirds: median, interval, worst and best real return after starts in each third. Every row has fewer than five independent periods. Earnings-yield thirds are labelled by valuation: a low yield is the dearest third. Yield-gap thirds are left out while bond yields are withheld.
Every signal in thirds: median, interval, worst and best real return after starts in each third. Every row has fewer than five independent periods. Earnings-yield thirds are labelled by valuation: a low yield is the dearest third. Yield-gap thirds are left out while bond yields are withheld.
Signal
Horizon
Start
Median real return, % a year
90% interval, low
90% interval, high
Independent periods
Worst
Best
Signal range
More
Sensex CAPE (IIMA)
5 years
Cheapest third
12.8%
9.0%
29.2%
1.4
3.7%
43.4%
12.1 to 19.9
Sensex CAPE (IIMA)
5 years
Middle third
7.7%
2.9%
9.8%
1.4
−2.9%
29.0%
19.9 to 24.4
Sensex CAPE (IIMA)
5 years
Dearest third
2.3%
−4.7%
6.7%
1.4
−10.4%
19.9%
24.5 to 48.5
Sensex CAPE (IIMA)
10 years
Cheapest third
10.7%
–
–
0.6
5.4%
15.4%
12.1 to 19.2
Sensex CAPE (IIMA)
10 years
Middle third
8.6%
–
–
0.6
4.6%
14.5%
19.2 to 23.8
Sensex CAPE (IIMA)
10 years
Dearest third
2.8%
–
–
0.6
−0.7%
8.7%
23.9 to 48.5
Nifty 500 CAPE (IIMA)
5 years
Cheapest third
9.7%
8.3%
10.3%
1.0
1.4%
19.1%
15.1 to 21.1
Nifty 500 CAPE (IIMA)
5 years
Middle third
6.2%
2.6%
8.9%
1.0
−2.9%
17.8%
21.3 to 27.0
Nifty 500 CAPE (IIMA)
5 years
Dearest third
3.4%
−2.2%
8.3%
1.0
−10.4%
19.9%
27.1 to 50.2
Nifty 500 CAPE (IIMA)
10 years
Cheapest third
9.0%
–
–
0.3
7.5%
11.2%
15.1 to 19.5
Nifty 500 CAPE (IIMA)
10 years
Middle third
8.3%
–
–
0.3
−0.0%
10.1%
19.7 to 26.1
Nifty 500 CAPE (IIMA)
10 years
Dearest third
2.4%
–
–
0.3
−0.7%
8.3%
26.4 to 50.2
Nifty 500 earnings yield
5 years
Dearest third
8.8%
1.2%
9.8%
1.5
−10.4%
19.9%
2.8% to 5.3%
Nifty 500 earnings yield
5 years
Middle third
4.2%
2.1%
9.9%
1.5
−9.5%
29.0%
5.3% to 6.8%
Nifty 500 earnings yield
5 years
Cheapest third
11.2%
7.0%
31.4%
1.5
−6.1%
43.4%
6.8% to 11.2%
Nifty 500 earnings yield
10 years
Dearest third
8.5%
–
–
0.6
−0.7%
14.5%
3.5% to 6.1%
Nifty 500 earnings yield
10 years
Middle third
6.2%
–
–
0.6
−0.0%
14.7%
6.1% to 7.0%
Nifty 500 earnings yield
10 years
Cheapest third
9.4%
–
–
0.6
2.8%
15.4%
7.1% to 11.2%
Every start month is in the published data (JSON), and the test in its own bundle. Both were written down before they were computed: C1 in the specification and results log, and D1, which replaced C1's statistics after an audit found its Newey-West errors far too small for samples like these. Sources: IIMA's Indian Valuation Index, NSE (P/E, P/B and total return indices), all-India CPI.
Market value against GDP
The market value of NSE-listed companies is 136% of last year's GDP (Oct 2026), higher than in 91% of months since 1999; the peak was 162% in Sept 2024. Since 1999 the ratio has risen 5.4-fold while the Nifty 50's P/E rose 1.7-fold, so most of the rise came from listed companies and their earnings growing faster than GDP, not from dearer prices. Its own past is a poor yardstick.
Market value of NSE-listed companies, % of GDP
Month-end market value against the previous complete financial year's nominal GDP (latest estimates).
How to read it. The long climb is mostly listings and earnings outgrowing GDP. Compare the swings, not the level.
Loading chart…
Source: NSE market capitalisation of listed companies; MoSPI nominal GDP (latest vintage).
Neither version has said much about the next five years. The raw ratio's slope is negative, but 64% of it is what chance produces in a sample of 5.4 independent periods (bootstrap p 0.22), and out of sample it did worse than the average (−37%). The ten-year gap fits better out of sample (46%), but on only 1.5 independent periods of forecasts, with a bootstrap p of 0.38. Both tests were written down before they were run (C22), and neither passes.
A check on my CAPE
My CAPE is computed from NSE's published P/E and CPI; IIMA's Indian Valuation Index builds its own. Before my adjustment for NSE's 2021 earnings switch, which IIMA does not make, the two track each other closely: a correlation of 0.995 over 213 months, with mine 1.007× IIMA's at the median.
Nifty 500 CAPE: mine against IIMA's
Monthly. IIMA's Indian Valuation Index, cited.
How to read it. The first two lines use the same earnings basis and should overlap. The adjusted line sits lower because it restates pre-2021 earnings on the consolidated basis, which raises them. On that basis the Nifty 500's CAPE is at its 84th percentile since 2009; the truth likely lies between the two, since the adjustment assumes the standalone-to-consolidated gap never changed.
Source: NSE Indices published PE, PB and dividend yield; CPI from IndiaDataHub (MoSPI, spliced). IIMA India CAPE: Jacob, J. and Raju, R. (2024), Forecast or Fallacy? Shiller's CAPE: Market and Style Factor Forward Returns in Indian Equities, https://capeindia.iima.ac.in/
Damodaran's 1 Jul 2026 reference edition puts India's equity risk premium at 6.92%. This is a country-adjusted required premium above a default-free rate. It is not a return forecast derived from today's Nifty price.
India equity risk premium
6.92%
Reference edition: 1 Jul 2026
Mature-market premium
4.20%
Reference edition: 1 Jul 2026
India country-risk premium
2.72%
Reference edition: 1 Jul 2026
India's Baa3 sovereign rating maps to a 1.75% default spread. Multiplying that spread by the workbook's 1.5545 equity-to-bond volatility ratio gives the country premium. Adding the mature-market premium gives the total ERP.
The same market premium, different country risk
Reference edition: 1 Jul 2026. Default spreads corrected on July 9, 2026.
How to read it. Each bar adds the common mature-market premium to the country's rating-based risk premium. A larger bar means the model assigns more compensation for country risk; it does not mean the market offers a higher realised return.
Mature-market premiumCountry-risk premium
Loading chart…
Source: Aswath Damodaran, NYU Stern, country risk workbook
Default spreads corrected on July 9, 2026. Source captured 5 Oct 2026. This is a dated reference, not a daily estimate. The US is excluded from these bars because its premium is estimated directly from market cash flows. Company exposure depends on where it operates; an India incorporation alone does not determine its country premium. Source workbook · Damodaran's methodology.