Data to 20 November 2026
About

ToolsPortfolio lab

What does a SIP really return?

Rs 10,000 a month in the Nifty 500, started in any month since Feb 1995 and held ten years, returned a median 13.8% a year after costs and tax. Held one year, the same SIP lost money 30% of the time; from 9 years on, no start month ended below zero. What follows is every holding period from 1 to 20 years, for equity, bonds, gold and simple mixes, and the Sensex back to 1979.

Written for anyone running a SIP, or deciding whether to start one. Data to 13 Nov 2026.

What a SIP returned, held 1 to 20 years

Each start month is one SIP: Rs 10,000 on the first trading day of every month, sold in full at the end, after fund costs and capital-gains tax. The spread across start months is the honest answer to "what will my SIP return": it depends heavily on how long you hold, and much less on what you hold once you hold long enough.

Nifty 500 SIP: the range of returns narrows as you hold longer

After-tax XIRR by holding period, every start month from Feb 1995, per cent a year

How to read it. Each holding period is a column of outcomes, one per start month. The line is the median; the dark band holds the middle half, the pale band nine in ten. The dashed grey line is the same instalments in fixed deposits. Held one year, outcomes ran from −30% to 69%; held ten, from 9% to 25%.

MedianMiddle half of start monthsNine in tenFixed deposits, median
1 year5101520 years−40%−20%0%20%40%60%80%9 in 10 start months fell in the pale bandhalf in the darker bandMedian 14.0%FD 5.2%
At 10 and 20 years there are only 3 and 1 separate, non-overlapping periods in this history: neighbouring start months share most of their months, so read the bands as a description of the past, not as odds.
Source: tipsheet portfolio lab: NSE total-return indices, NSE's 10-year benchmark G-sec index (total return; rebuilt from RBI yields before 2001), RBI's domestic gold price linked to WGC's, RBI's bank deposit rates for fixed deposits, and all-India CPI. Sensex: BSE's daily closes and dividend yields.

Every asset on one scale

Pure equity first, then the 10-year G-sec, gold, and three simple mixes rebalanced each January. Same scale throughout, so a narrow funnel means a steadier SIP. Each panel uses its own longest history; the Midcap and Smallcap indices start in Apr 2005, so their funnels rest on fewer years.

Nifty 50

Starts from Jul 1999

15101520−10%0%10%20%30%40%12.6%5.2%

Nifty 500

Starts from Feb 1995

15101520−10%0%10%20%30%40%14.0%5.2%

Nifty Midcap 150

Starts from Apr 2005

15101520−10%0%10%20%30%40%15.9%5.1%

Nifty Smallcap 250

Starts from Apr 2005

15101520−10%0%10%20%30%40%13.7%5.1%

G-sec, 10-year

Starts from Jun 1996

15101520−10%0%10%20%30%40%6.0%5.2%

Gold

Starts from Feb 1995

15101520−10%0%10%20%30%40%9.5%5.2%

60/40 equity and G-sec

Starts from Jun 1996

15101520−10%0%10%20%30%40%11.7%5.2%

60/20/20 equity, G-sec and gold

Starts from Jun 1996

15101520−10%0%10%20%30%40%12.7%5.2%

Equal thirds: equity, G-sec and gold

Starts from Jun 1996

15101520−10%0%10%20%30%40%11.2%5.2%

Sensex, price only

Starts from Apr 1979; no costs or tax

15101520−10%0%10%20%30%40%13.1%8.5%

Median line in colour, middle half dark, nine in ten pale; dashed grey is fixed deposits. After-tax XIRR, per cent a year, on a scale of −10% to 40%; the short holding periods of equity run off it.

The medians, by holding period

Median after-tax XIRR across start months, per cent a year. Sensex rows are before costs and tax. The worst 10-year start, and the independent 10-year periods it rests on.

Median after-tax XIRR across start months, per cent a year. Sensex rows are before costs and tax. The worst 10-year start, and the independent 10-year periods it rests on.
SIP inStarts from1 yr3 yrs5 yrs10 yrs15 yrs20 yrsWorst 10-yr (start)Separate 10-yr periodsMore
Nifty 50Jul 199910.5%13.6%13.3%12.6%12.5%12.6%3.4% (Apr 2010)2
Nifty 500Feb 19959.6%14.1%14.2%13.8%14.0%14.0%3.4% (Apr 2010)3
Nifty Midcap 150Apr 200511.9%19.2%17.8%16.8%16.4%15.9%5.2% (Apr 2010)2
Nifty Smallcap 250Apr 200510.7%17.8%16.6%14.5%14.1%13.7%−1.1% (Apr 2010)2
G-sec, 10-yearJun 19965.3%5.1%5.1%5.6%5.7%6.0%3.4% (Nov 2001)3
GoldFeb 19955.6%7.3%9.3%9.4%10.0%9.5%2.4% (Jun 1995)3
60/40 equity and G-secJun 19968.7%11.4%11.3%11.0%11.1%11.7%5.5% (Apr 2010)3
60/20/20 equity, G-sec and goldJun 199610.0%12.1%12.1%12.5%12.2%12.7%5.4% (Apr 2010)3
Equal thirds: equity, G-sec and goldJun 19968.2%10.3%11.1%11.4%11.0%11.2%6.2% (Apr 2010)3
Sensex, price onlyApr 197912.9%13.5%13.5%13.3%13.3%13.1%−3.7% (Oct 1991)4
Sensex, with dividendsJan 199113.0%12.7%12.4%13.5%14.8%14.1%−2.2% (Oct 1991)3

On equal footing: everyone from the same start months

After-tax XIRR across start months from April 2005, per cent a year

How to read it. Same start months for every row, so midcaps and smallcaps can be set against the rest fairly. The dot is the median, the bar the middle half; the shaded column is fixed deposits. On the right, the separate periods behind each row.

On equal footing: everyone from the same start months. 3 horizons, 9 bands. Nifty 50: median +12.1%, 7 periods; Nifty 500: median +13.8%, 7 periods; Nifty Midcap 150: median +19.2%, 7 periods; Nifty Smallcap 250: median +17.8%, 7 periods; G-sec, 5-year: median +6.1%, 7 periods; Gold: median +10.0%, 7 periods; 60/40: median +10.8%, 7 periods; 60/20/20: median +11.3%, 7 periods; Equal thirds: median +9.5%, 7 periods. Fixed deposit: median +5.1%.

Source: tipsheet portfolio lab: NSE total-return indices, NSE's 10-year benchmark G-sec index (total return; rebuilt from RBI yields before 2001), RBI's domestic gold price linked to WGC's, RBI's bank deposit rates for fixed deposits, and all-India CPI. Sensex: BSE's daily closes and dividend yields.
Method

How often a SIP lost money, or lost to FDs, G-sec and gold

By start year: when equity lost to gold, G-sec and FDs

The usual worry is not the median but the bad draw. For each holding period, the share of start months in which the SIP finished below zero, or behind the same instalments put into fixed deposits, the 10-year G-sec, gold, or inflation. The alternatives are taxed the same way.

Nifty 500 SIP: how often it fell short, by holding period

Share of start months from Feb 1995, per cent; columns are years held

How to read it. Read across a row. Behind FDs in 17% of 5-year SIPs and 0% of 10-year ones. Gold was the hardest yardstick: the Nifty 500 SIP trailed it in 24% of 10-year windows.

Nifty 500 SIP: how often it fell short, by holding period. Heat table, 5 rows by 20 columns. Values from 0% to 44%.

Source: tipsheet portfolio lab: NSE total-return indices, NSE's 10-year benchmark G-sec index (total return; rebuilt from RBI yields before 2001), RBI's domestic gold price linked to WGC's, RBI's bank deposit rates for fixed deposits, and all-India CPI. Sensex: BSE's daily closes and dividend yields.

Every asset: how often the SIP ended below zero

Share of start months with an after-tax XIRR below zero, per cent; columns are years held

How to read it. Over one year every asset lost money in a real share of start months, from 12% to 35%, bonds and mixes included. By five years the G-sec and the mixes had all but stopped losing money. Gold had not: it ended below zero in 13% of 5-year SIPs, against 7% for the Nifty 500.

Every asset: how often the SIP ended below zero. Heat table, 9 rows by 20 columns. Values from 0% to 35%.

Source: tipsheet portfolio lab: NSE total-return indices, NSE's 10-year benchmark G-sec index (total return; rebuilt from RBI yields before 2001), RBI's domestic gold price linked to WGC's, RBI's bank deposit rates for fixed deposits, and all-India CPI. Sensex: BSE's daily closes and dividend yields.

Every asset: how often the SIP trailed fixed deposits

Share of start months behind the same instalments in fixed deposits, after tax, per cent

How to read it. The G-sec SIP trailed FDs in 50% of 5-year and 33% of 10-year windows: a government bond and a bank deposit pay similar rates, and the bond's price swings cut both ways. Gold trailed FDs in 13% of 10-year windows; equity almost never did by then.

Every asset: how often the SIP trailed fixed deposits. Heat table, 9 rows by 20 columns. Values from 0% to 53%.

Source: tipsheet portfolio lab: NSE total-return indices, NSE's 10-year benchmark G-sec index (total return; rebuilt from RBI yields before 2001), RBI's domestic gold price linked to WGC's, RBI's bank deposit rates for fixed deposits, and all-India CPI. Sensex: BSE's daily closes and dividend yields.

After inflation

A 12% SIP in a year of 6% inflation is a 6% SIP in what money buys. Each instalment and the final value are deflated by the consumer price index of their month; the XIRR of those flows is the real return.

Nifty 500 SIP after inflation, by holding period

Real after-tax XIRR, median and middle half of start months, per cent a year

How to read it. Held ten years, the median real return was 7.5% a year, and 2% of start months failed to beat inflation. Held one or two years, about 40% did.

1 year5101520 years−10%−5%0%5%10%15%20%25%Median 6.9%
Source: tipsheet portfolio lab: NSE total-return indices, NSE's 10-year benchmark G-sec index (total return; rebuilt from RBI yields before 2001), RBI's domestic gold price linked to WGC's, RBI's bank deposit rates for fixed deposits, and all-India CPI. Sensex: BSE's daily closes and dividend yields.

What inflation took from a ten-year SIP

Median ten-year after-tax XIRR, before and after inflation, per cent a year

How to read it. Each row runs from the real return to the nominal one. Inflation took between 5.8 points and 7.0 points a year from every asset; what is left is the gap between them. The G-sec SIP's median real return was −0.2%.

After inflationBefore inflation

What inflation took from a ten-year SIP. Range chart of 9 items. After inflation: highest Nifty Midcap 150 at 10.6%, lowest G-sec, 10-year at −0.2%.

Source: tipsheet portfolio lab: NSE total-return indices, NSE's 10-year benchmark G-sec index (total return; rebuilt from RBI yields before 2001), RBI's domestic gold price linked to WGC's, RBI's bank deposit rates for fixed deposits, and all-India CPI. Sensex: BSE's daily closes and dividend yields.

Every asset: how often the SIP lost to inflation

Share of start months with a real after-tax XIRR below zero, per cent; columns are years held

Every asset: how often the SIP lost to inflation. Heat table, 9 rows by 20 columns. Values from 0% to 90%.

Source: tipsheet portfolio lab: NSE total-return indices, NSE's 10-year benchmark G-sec index (total return; rebuilt from RBI yields before 2001), RBI's domestic gold price linked to WGC's, RBI's bank deposit rates for fixed deposits, and all-India CPI. Sensex: BSE's daily closes and dividend yields.

Does it matter when you start?

Thirty years of start dates, every portfolio

Over ten years it mattered a great deal, and not in a way anyone could have timed. Ten-year Nifty 500 SIPs started in 1997 made a median 25.3% a year; those started in 2010, 9.3%. What decides it is mostly where the market ends, not where it starts.

A ten-year SIP, by the month it began

After-tax XIRR of each ten-year SIP, by start month, per cent a year

How to read it. Each point is a whole ten-year SIP, plotted at its start. Neighbouring points share most of their months, so the line moves in long swings. The Nifty 500's worst start, Apr 2010, ended in the crash of spring 2020; gold's best start was Mar 2016.

A ten-year SIP, by the month it began. Line chart, Feb 1995 to Nov 2016. Nifty 500: latest 11.1%, range 3.4% to 31.6%. Gold: latest 18.0%, range 2.4% to 22.9%. G-sec, 10-year: latest 4.4%, range 3.4% to 9.9%. Fixed deposits: latest 5.0%, range 5.0% to 6.0%.

Source: tipsheet portfolio lab: NSE total-return indices, NSE's 10-year benchmark G-sec index (total return; rebuilt from RBI yields before 2001), RBI's domestic gold price linked to WGC's, RBI's bank deposit rates for fixed deposits, and all-India CPI. Sensex: BSE's daily closes and dividend yields.

Median ten-year SIP by start year

After-tax XIRR, per cent a year, median of the twelve start months of each year

How to read it. Darker is higher. Columns are start years; the last full column is the latest year with ten years behind it.

Median ten-year SIP by start year. Heat table, 7 rows by 22 columns. Values from 3 to 25.

Source: tipsheet portfolio lab: NSE total-return indices, NSE's 10-year benchmark G-sec index (total return; rebuilt from RBI yields before 2001), RBI's domestic gold price linked to WGC's, RBI's bank deposit rates for fixed deposits, and all-India CPI. Sensex: BSE's daily closes and dividend yields.

Starting at a market high did not doom a SIP. Ten-year Nifty 500 SIPs started within 2% of an all-time high made a median 12.3%; those started more than 20% below one made 12.3%. Monthly instalments buy through whatever comes next. Starting at a high, in detail.

Have SIP returns fallen? The Sensex since 1979

The Sensex has daily data back to April 1979, longer than any other Indian index I hold. A SIP in it is shown before costs and tax, since no index fund existed until 2001. The price index leaves out dividends; BSE's dividend yield is measured only from 1991, so the version with dividends starts then.

A ten-year Sensex SIP, by the month it began

XIRR of each ten-year SIP, by start month, per cent a year, before costs and tax

How to read it. The starts of 1979-89 are the high plateau on the left. After them, the median ten-year SIP by decade stayed between 10.9% and 12.6%, while the swings between start months narrowed. The grey line is fixed deposits before tax, whose rates have fallen.

A ten-year Sensex SIP, by the month it began. Line chart, Apr 1979 to Nov 2016. Sensex, price only: latest 8.8%, range −3.7% to 43.6%. Sensex, with dividends: latest 10.1%, range −2.2% to 29.4%. Fixed deposits: latest 7.4%, range 7.4% to 11.9%.

Source: BSE Sensex daily closes from 3 Apr 1979 and BSE's published dividend yield (measured from 2 Jan 1991); fixed deposits at RBI's deposit rates, before tax; CPI: all-India CPI from October 1988, the OECD's India CPI (FRED) before it.

Median ten-year Sensex SIP, by the decade it began

XIRR, per cent a year; 1979 starts count with the 1980s

How to read it. The fall is one step, not a slope: from 23.0% for 1979-89 starts to 10.9% for 1990s starts, then 11.6% and 12.6%. With dividends, the 2010s did better than the 1990s. After inflation the 1980s still lead, but by less.

Price onlyWith dividends (from 1991)Price only, after inflation

Median ten-year Sensex SIP, by the decade it began. Bar chart of 4 items. Price only: highest 1979-89 starts at 23.0%, lowest 1990s starts at 10.9%.

Source: BSE Sensex daily closes from 3 Apr 1979 and BSE's published dividend yield (measured from 2 Jan 1991); fixed deposits at RBI's deposit rates, before tax; CPI: all-India CPI from October 1988, the OECD's India CPI (FRED) before it.

A fifteen-year Sensex SIP, by the month it began

XIRR of each fifteen-year SIP, by start month, per cent a year, before costs and tax

How to read it. Over fifteen years the decline is steadier: medians of 16.9% for 1979-89 starts, 14.2% for the 1990s, 12.2% for the 2000s, and 11.6% for the few 2010s starts with fifteen years behind them.

A fifteen-year Sensex SIP, by the month it began. Line chart, Apr 1979 to Nov 2011. Sensex, price only: latest 9.8%, range 5.3% to 29.6%. Sensex, with dividends: latest 11.2%, range 7.3% to 20.7%. Fixed deposits: latest 7.4%, range 7.4% to 11.5%.

Source: BSE Sensex daily closes from 3 Apr 1979 and BSE's published dividend yield (measured from 2 Jan 1991); fixed deposits at RBI's deposit rates, before tax; CPI: all-India CPI from October 1988, the OECD's India CPI (FRED) before it.

So yes, but with care. The price-only Sensex SIP's best decade was the first: 1979-89 starts made a median 23.0% over ten years. Inflation was higher then too, and in real terms the lead shrinks from 10.4 points to 5.5 points. Since 1990 there is no steady decline at ten years: the decade medians sit within 1.8 points of each other, and the 2010s were the highest of the three. At fifteen years the medians fell every decade, from 16.9% to 11.6%, but the 2010s figure rests on only 23 start months.

Dividends matter more than most charts admit. The price index you see quoted leaves them out; adding BSE's published yield back raised the median ten-year SIP by 1.5 points a year. The rebuilt series tracks NSE's Nifty 50 total-return index from 2001 with a monthly correlation of 0.993 and a compound return within 0.16 points a year.

Sensex SIPs by start decade, before costs and tax. XIRR per cent a year: median, middle half, and real median; the FD column is the same instalments in fixed deposits.

Sensex SIPs by start decade, before costs and tax. XIRR per cent a year: median, middle half, and real median; the FD column is the same instalments in fixed deposits.
Years heldSeriesStartsStart monthsSeparate periods25th pctMedian75th pctReal medianFD medianMore
10Price only1979-89129219.0%23.0%28.7%12.7%10.9%
10Price only1990s12014.2%10.9%18.9%4.7%8.9%
10Price only2000s120110.1%11.6%14.1%4.0%7.8%
10Price only2010s83111.2%12.6%13.2%7.1%7.5%
10With dividends1990s10813.6%12.8%21.6%7.5%8.4%
10With dividends2000s120111.7%13.1%15.9%5.5%7.8%
10With dividends2010s83112.5%14.0%14.5%8.3%7.5%
15Price only1979-89129110.6%16.9%21.8%7.1%11.2%
15Price only1990s120113.2%14.2%15.5%7.0%8.5%
15Price only2000s120111.3%12.2%13.1%5.3%7.6%
15Price only2010s23110.5%11.6%12.1%6.2%7.5%
15With dividends1990s108115.2%16.2%17.3%8.9%8.3%
15With dividends2000s120112.7%13.6%14.8%6.7%7.6%
15With dividends2010s23111.9%12.9%13.5%7.5%7.5%

The ride: how far below, and for how long

How bad a SIP gets, from 2005, every portfolio

A ten-year XIRR hides the years in between. Almost every equity SIP spends time below the money put into it: 97% of Sensex SIPs started since 1979 did. What separates them is how deep and how long.

How often a Sensex SIP was under water, by how long it had been running

Share of Sensex SIPs (price only) started from Apr 1979, at each age, per cent

How to read it. Six months in, 35% were below the money put in. Behind fixed deposits is the more stubborn state: 34% of SIPs were still there at three years, 27% at five and 16% at ten.

Below the money put inBelow the same money in FDsBelow inflation

How often a Sensex SIP was under water, by how long it had been running. Bar chart of 8 items. Below the money put in: highest 6 months at 35%, lowest 15 years at 0%.

Source: BSE Sensex daily closes from 3 Apr 1979 and BSE's published dividend yield (measured from 2 Jan 1991); fixed deposits at RBI's deposit rates, before tax; CPI: all-India CPI from October 1988, the OECD's India CPI (FRED) before it.

The deepest a Sensex SIP fell below the money put in, by the month it began

Worst point of each SIP's statement value against the money invested so far, per cent

How to read it. The deepest was a SIP started in Oct 2007: by 27 Oct 2008 it was 48% below what had gone in. SIPs that began before a crash fell furthest, because they had the most money in when it came.

The deepest a Sensex SIP fell below the money put in, by the month it began. Area chart, Apr 1979 to Sept 2026. Sensex SIP, price only: latest −6%, range −48% to 0%.

Source: BSE Sensex daily closes from 3 Apr 1979 and BSE's published dividend yield (measured from 2 Jan 1991); fixed deposits at RBI's deposit rates, before tax; CPI: all-India CPI from October 1988, the OECD's India CPI (FRED) before it.

The longest stretches

Longest run of month-ends a SIP spent in each state, across all start months

How to read it. The Sensex SIP started in Feb 1992 spent 10 years 5 months behind the same money in fixed deposits, on the price index; with dividends, the longest such stretch was 4 years 11 months. Below the money put in, the longest was 3 years 4 months, from a Dec 1999 start.

Below the money put inBelow the same money in FDsBelow inflation

The longest stretches. Bar chart of 8 items. Below the money put in: highest Gold at 67, lowest Equal thirds at 13.

Source: tipsheet portfolio lab: NSE total-return indices, NSE's 10-year benchmark G-sec index (total return; rebuilt from RBI yields before 2001), RBI's domestic gold price linked to WGC's, RBI's bank deposit rates for fixed deposits, and all-India CPI. Sensex: BSE's daily closes and dividend yields.

Does a clever SIP do better?

Timing, dips and dates, every portfolio

Valuation-based SIPs, stopping in a crash, buying the dips, the right date, weekly instalments. Each was run on the same start months as a plain Nifty 500 SIP, with the same money: whatever a rule does not invest waits in a liquid fund and counts at the end.

Only waiting for a crash came out ahead, and it rests on two crashes

Median difference in ten-year after-tax XIRR against a plain Nifty 500 SIP on the same start months, points

How to read it. Bars left of zero lost to the plain SIP. The valuation SIP that invests more when the CAPE is low trailed by 0.27 points; the yield-gap version by 1.60 points. Stopping in a crash and keeping the cash cost 1.48 points, and the plain SIP won in 99% of windows.

Only waiting for a crash came out ahead, and it rests on two crashes. Bar chart of 11 items. Median difference: highest Buy dips: when 20% below the peak at +0.74 pts, lowest Valuation SIP: more when the yield gap is wide at −1.60 pts.

Source: tipsheet portfolio lab: NSE total-return indices, NSE's 10-year benchmark G-sec index (total return; rebuilt from RBI yields before 2001), RBI's domestic gold price linked to WGC's, RBI's bank deposit rates for fixed deposits, and all-India CPI. Sensex: BSE's daily closes and dividend yields.

Why the valuation SIP lost: Indian markets looked expensive on the CAPE for most of the last decade, so the rule kept money in a liquid fund through a rising market. Buying after daily falls of 1%, 2% or 3% made no real difference either way, because such falls come every few weeks and the cash never waits long.

The exception looks better than it is. Holding every instalment in a liquid fund until the Nifty 500 is 20% below its peak, then investing the lot, finished 0.74 points ahead at the median ten-year window. But only two such falls happened in these windows, 2008 and 2020; the average gain across all windows was 0.10 points; on the windows that do not overlap it lost 0.75 points; and over five years it trailed by 1.84 points. The median window ended with 4.9 lakh rupees still in cash, waiting. It is a bet on the next crash arriving in time, not a better SIP. Dip-buying, in detail.

Where SIPs stand today

Every SIP started in a month from April 2005 to a year ago, valued on 13 Nov 2026 as if sold that day, after tax. Fund statements show this figure before tax and without selling. Of the SIPs started in the last 36 months, 3 in gold would return less than went in.

Equity indices: a SIP's XIRR today, by the month it began

After-tax XIRR to 13 Nov 2026, per cent a year

How to read it. Read each panel from the right. The latest starts have had only a year or two, so they swing with the last few months of the market; the older starts have had time to settle. Below zero, the SIP is worth less than what went in.

Equity indices: a SIP's XIRR today, by the month it began. Small multiples, Apr 2005 to Nov 2025. Nifty 50: latest 5.8%, range 3.4% to 11.3%. Nifty 100: latest 6.2%, range 3.8% to 11.6%. Nifty 500: latest 6.2%, range 4.2% to 12.6%. Nifty LargeMidcap 250: latest 5.2%, range 4.3% to 14.0%. Nifty Midcap 150: latest 4.6%, range 4.6% to 17.3%. Nifty Smallcap 250: latest 10.1%, range 4.9% to 17.6%.

Source: tipsheet portfolio lab: NSE total-return indices, NSE's 10-year benchmark G-sec index (total return; rebuilt from RBI yields before 2001), RBI's domestic gold price linked to WGC's, RBI's bank deposit rates for fixed deposits, and all-India CPI. Sensex: BSE's daily closes and dividend yields.

Common questions

How long before a SIP stops losing money?

In this history, a Nifty 500 SIP held 9 years or more never ended below zero after tax, and one held 14 years or more never trailed fixed deposits. The Sensex, with a longer and rougher history, needed 13 years to clear zero every time. Before five years, losses are common.

SIP or lump sum?

If the money is already in hand, investing it at once beat moving it in over twelve months (an STP) in 59% to 71% of start months, because markets rise more often than they fall. A SIP is the answer for money that arrives monthly, from a salary; that is its real job. Compared the way most articles do it, the ten-year Nifty 500 SIP's XIRR beat the lump sum's CAGR in 61% of start months, but those are two different investors.

Does the SIP date matter?

Barely. Over ten years, no date of the month moved the Nifty 500 SIP's median by more than 0.14 points a year against the 1st. Late-month dates did a little better over short horizons, through a known turn-of-month effect. By date.

Should I step up my SIP every year?

A step-up barely changes the return; it changes the corpus because more money goes in. A 10% annual step-up left the ten-year Nifty 500 median XIRR at 12.8% and raised the median final value to 33.9 lakh rupees. Step-ups.

Direct or regular plan?

An extra 1% a year in running costs, about the gap between a regular and a direct plan, left a fifteen-year Nifty 500 SIP with a median 9% less money at the end (6% at ten years). Costs.

What does starting five years late cost?

To end with the median twenty-year Nifty 500 corpus in fifteen years, the instalment had to be about Rs 20,796 a month instead of Rs 10,000. Starting late.

What did a SIP make in a single calendar year?

Calendar-year SIP returns swing far more than ten-year ones, and the worst point inside a year is often much lower than where the year ends. Year by year.

How this was done

  • The SIP. Rs 10,000 on the first trading day of each month, every start month in each series' history. A SIP's return is its XIRR: the annual rate that makes the instalments grow into the final value.
  • Costs and tax. Index-fund or ETF running costs by date, stamp duty, and capital-gains tax for a 30% slab investor under the rules of each year, with everything sold at the end. Fixed deposits pay RBI's deposit rate, interest taxed each year. The Sensex rows are before costs and tax, and so is their FD line.
  • The series. Nifty 50 and Nifty 500 total-return indices; NSE's 10-year G-sec index from 2001, rebuilt from RBI yields before that; RBI's domestic gold price linked to WGC's. The Midcap and Smallcap indices start in April 2005, and their early years are NSE's back-test.
  • Overlap. SIPs that start a month apart share almost every month, so a 20-year funnel built from three hundred start months rests on one or two separate periods of history. The counts are on every table.
  • Pre-registered. The questions and predictions were written down before anything was computed. Below are the six for this view; earlier ones are on the numbers page and the sub-pages.

S17 Held

The median 10-year SIP XIRR on the price-only Sensex of 1980s starts exceeds that of 2010s starts by more than 5 points.

1979-89 starts: 23.0%; 2010s starts: 12.6%, a gap of 10.4 points.

S18 Failed

On the total-return Sensex, the median 10-year SIP XIRR of 1990s starts exceeds that of 2010s starts by more than 2 points.

1990s starts (from 1991): 12.8%; 2010s starts: 14.0%. The later decade did better, by 1.2 points.

S19 Failed

In real terms the gap in S17 is less than half the nominal gap, because inflation fell over the same decades.

After inflation the gap is 5.5 points, against half the nominal gap, 5.2 points. Falling inflation explains a little under half of the fall, not more.

S20 Held

At the median 10-year window from 1991, the rebuilt total return adds between 1 and 2 points a year to the Sensex SIP's XIRR over the price index.

Dividends added a median 1.54 points a year.

S21 Held

At least one 10-year SIP on the price-only Sensex started from 1979 had a negative real XIRR.

The worst real 10-year XIRR was −9.9%.

S22 Held

For each equity portfolio in the long-history set, the share of start months with an after-tax XIRR below zero is under 5% by the 7-year horizon.

Nifty 50: 0.0%; Nifty 500: 2.3% of 7-year SIPs ended below zero.

Historical research on index portfolios, not investment advice. Returns are after fund costs; "after tax" applies Indian capital-gains rules by date for a 30% slab investor and sells everything at the end. Samples start in 1995-96 for the Nifty 500, G-sec, gold and mixes, 1999 for the Nifty 50, 2005 for the Midcap and Smallcap indices (back-tested by NSE before their launch) and 1979 for the Sensex (before costs and tax). Domestic assets only. The fixed-deposit rate is banks' 1-3 year deposit rate (RBI Handbook Table 74 to July 2010, then RBI's weekly rate for deposits over a year, maximum), interest taxed each year at the 30% slab plus cess.

The workings