Data to 20 November 2026
About

Tools

How did Golden butterfly do after costs and tax?

20% each in Nifty 500 TRI, Nifty Smallcap 250 TRI, long G-secs (synthetic 10-year), cash and gold, rebalanced each January. From Apr 2005 to Nov 2026 it compounded at 12.3% a year after costs and tax (12.9% before tax), against 11.6% after tax for 60/40. Its worst fall was −24%, bottoming in Oct 2008 and recovered by May 2009.

Written for investors weighing this allocation against a plain 60/40, and advisers who want its tax and cost drag measured. Data to 20 Nov 2026.

How it works

One of 141 portfolios in the lab, in the family "Named multi-asset portfolios". The rule and its parameters were written down before any result was computed.

Historical research on index portfolios, not investment advice. Returns are after fund costs; 'after tax' applies Indian capital-gains rules by date for a 30% slab investor and sells everything at the end. Most factor, mid-cap and small-cap index history before each index's launch date is back-tested by NSE. One 21-year sample, domestic assets only.

Construction
20% each in Nifty 500 TRI, Nifty Smallcap 250 TRI, long G-secs (synthetic 10-year), cash and gold, rebalanced each January.
Rebalancing
Rebalanced to its target weights at the first session of each January.
From the literature
Tyler, Portfolio Charts (the Golden Butterfly).
Substitutions
Small-cap value becomes Nifty Smallcap 250 (no small-cap value index); short-term Treasuries become the T-bill.
Back-tested history
Nifty Smallcap 250: NSE's back-test before 1 Apr 2016, live after.

Weights held, month-end, Apr 2005 to Nov 2026. The target is what each rebalance restores; between rebalances the weights drift with prices.

Weights held, month-end, Apr 2005 to Nov 2026. The target is what each rebalance restores; between rebalances the weights drift with prices.
AssetTargetAverage heldLowestHighestLatest (Nov 2026)More
Gold (domestic, rupees)20%21%14%30%19%
Nifty Smallcap 25020%20%7%30%21%
Nifty 50020%20%10%26%20%
Cash (91-day T-bill, as a liquid fund)20%20%15%27%21%
G-sec 10-year (NSE benchmark index; rebuilt from yields before 2001)20%19%12%29%20%

Growth and falls

What one rupee became, and how far it fell on the way. 60/40 is drawn in grey for comparison. Both curves are after fund costs and before tax; the after-tax figures are in the costs chapter.

Growth of 1 rupee

Weekly, shown month by month, Apr 2005 to Nov 2026. After costs, before tax. Log scale. Back-tested before launch: Nifty Smallcap 250 (live from Apr 2016).

How to read it. On a log scale equal slopes are equal rates of return. One rupee became 13.73× here and 11.86× in 60/40; a steeper line in one stretch says which did better then.

Golden butterfly60/40
201020201×2×5×10×13.7×11.9×
Source: tipsheet portfolio lab, computed from the 91-day T-bill yield, domestic gold in rupees (World Gold Council), NSE's 10-year benchmark G-sec index (total return; from 2001; rebuilt from month-end yields before that), NSE total-return indices.

Fall from the previous peak

The lowest weekly reading of each month, per cent below the highest value reached so far.

How to read it. Zero means a new high. The deepest fall here was −23.7% (Oct 2008), against −36.5% for 60/40. Depth is half the story: the width of each dip is how long an investor waited to get back to even.

per cent

Golden butterfly60/40
20102020−40%−30%−20%−10%0%−1%−5%
Source: tipsheet portfolio lab, computed from the 91-day T-bill yield, domestic gold in rupees (World Gold Council), NSE's 10-year benchmark G-sec index (total return; from 2001; rebuilt from month-end yields before that), NSE total-return indices.

The five deepest falls

Measured on daily values. Days are calendar days.

Measured on daily values. Days are calendar days.
FallPeakBottomBack to peakDays fallingDays below peakMore
−23.7%4 Jan 200824 Oct 200822 May 2009294504
−19.7%12 May 200614 Jun 200615 Jan 200733248
−16.2%24 Feb 202023 Mar 202023 Jul 202028150
−10.0%10 Nov 201010 Feb 20111 Feb 201292448
−9.6%7 Jan 20136 Aug 20135 Mar 2014211422

Year by year

Calendar-year returns, after costs and before tax, with 60/40 below for comparison. In 9 of 20 full years this portfolio did better. The market phases below are the lab's pre-registered splits.

Per cent. * Part year: Apr 2005 on, and to Nov 2026.
2026*202520242023202220212020201920182017201620152014201320122011201020092008200720062005*
Golden butterfly +2+18+16+21+4+19+17+8−2+21+7+4+250+20−5+12+42−13+37+19+24
60/40 +2+8+13+19+3+20+15+9+1+24+8+4+29+5+23−15+10+51−27+40+22+24

Annualised return and worst fall in each phase, after costs, before tax.

Annualised return and worst fall in each phase, after costs, before tax.
PhaseDatesA year60/40, a yearWorst fall60/40, worst fallMore
The boom, FY06 to FY08Apr 2005 to Mar 200822.4%20.9%−20%−22%
The crisis, FY09Apr 2008 to Mar 2009−5.1%−14.6%−18%−27%
FY10 to FY14Apr 2009 to Mar 201413.8%14.4%−10%−17%
FY15 to FY20 (to March 2020)Apr 2014 to Mar 20207.4%7.9%−16%−23%
April 2020 onApr 2020 to Nov 202616.3%15.3%−9%−11%

What costs and tax took

The same Apr 2005 to Nov 2026 run, peeled back one layer at a time. Fund costs are those of the cheapest widely available index fund or ETF of each era; tax applies Indian capital-gains rules as they stood on each sale date, and everything is sold at the end so deferred tax is counted. Turnover was 0.06 times the portfolio a year.

Annualised return (CAGR) at each layer, and what that layer cost in percentage points a year.

Annualised return (CAGR) at each layer, and what that layer cost in percentage points a year.
LayerGolden butterflyCost of this layer (pts)60/40More
Index return, before any cost13.57%–12.70%
After fund costs and trading (before tax)12.86%0.7112.10%
After tax, 30% slab12.26%0.6011.62%
After tax and inflation5.45%6.804.85%

After-tax CAGR under other tax assumptions. The headline keeps the annual equity exemption off because it depends on the investor's other gains.

After-tax CAGR under other tax assumptions. The headline keeps the annual equity exemption off because it depends on the investor's other gains.
Tax caseGolden butterfly60/40
30% slab, equity exemption off (the headline)12.26%11.62%
30% slab, equity exemption on (Rs 10 lakh start)12.29%11.65%
20% slab12.26%11.62%

How sure I can be

One 21-year history is one draw. These numbers say how much the result could move with a different ordering of the same months, and how it looks once the 141 portfolios tried are taken into account.

Return, 90% interval
9.6% to 16.4% a year before tax (block bootstrap of monthly returns; the point estimate is 12.9%).
Against 60/40, 90% interval
−1.2 pts to +2.7 pts a year. The interval straddles zero: the history cannot tell this portfolio and 60/40 apart.
Five-year windows ahead of 60/40
51% of rolling five-year windows. The windows overlap: only about 4 of them are independent, so this is a description of the past, not a probability.
Longest stretch below its best against 60/40
5,475 days: the longest run its wealth relative to 60/40 spent below an earlier high of that ratio. Not time behind 60/40; it can be ahead throughout.
Deflated Sharpe against 60/40
0.00. This is the probability that its edge over 60/40 is real once 141 tries are allowed for; 0.95 would be the usual bar.
Worst five years after inflation
−0.5% a year
Rolling five-year return
Lowest 4.5%, middle half 9.9% to 13.9%, highest 21.0% a year (before tax).

As a monthly SIP

Rs 10,000 a month, bought at the first session of each month, held for a fixed number of years and then sold, after costs and tax (with the annual equity exemption on). Each start month is one window. Windows that start a month apart share almost all their months, so the number of independent periods is printed next to every figure.

10-year SIP: after-tax return by start month

XIRR of each 10-year SIP, by the month it started (140 windows). Grey: the same instalments in one-year fixed deposits, taxed each year. The FD rate: banks' 1-3 year deposit rate (RBI Handbook Table 74 to July 2010, then RBI's weekly rate for deposits over a year, maximum), interest taxed each year at the 30% slab plus cess.

How to read it. Each point is a whole 10-year SIP. Neighbouring points share most of their months, so the line is far smoother than the evidence is deep. The best start was Mar 2016 (13.0%), the worst Apr 2010 (5.6%).

per cent a year, after tax

Golden butterfly SIPFixed-deposit SIP
201020154%6%8%10%12%14%11.3%5.0%
Source: tipsheet portfolio lab, computed from the 91-day T-bill yield, domestic gold in rupees (World Gold Council), NSE's 10-year benchmark G-sec index (total return; from 2001; rebuilt from month-end yields before that), NSE total-return indices.

The latest 10-year SIP in the data started in Nov 2016. It put in ₹12,00,000 and was worth ₹21,64,245 after tax at the end, against ₹15,50,847 for the same instalments in fixed deposits.

After-tax XIRR across start months, per cent a year. 'Below FD' and 'below inflation' are shares of overlapping windows, not probabilities.

After-tax XIRR across start months, per cent a year. 'Below FD' and 'below inflation' are shares of overlapping windows, not probabilities.
YearsWindowsIndependent periods5th pctMedian95th pctWorstWorst startBelow FDBelow inflationMedian valueMore
322472.3%10.8%17.3%−4.4%2017-0419%24%₹4,23,215
520045.9%10.8%15.8%1.0%2015-043%13%₹7,87,218
717637.4%10.5%14.1%3.9%2013-042%8%₹12,19,397
1014027.8%10.5%12.5%5.6%2010-040%0%₹20,71,324
158019.1%10.4%11.6%8.0%2005-040%0%₹41,73,688
2020110.8%11.1%11.4%10.6%2006-110%0%₹82,67,873

The workings

Method

Data

Every chart has a table view, a CSV download and a link to its published JSON. Bundles are listed in data status.

Read with