---
title: "SIP studies: pre-registered specification"
url: https://tipsheet.markets/research/sip_studies_spec/
description: "Pre-registered research specification and results log: SIP studies: pre-registered specification."
updated: 2026-10-29
publisher: tipsheet (https://tipsheet.markets/)
cite: "tipsheet, “SIP studies: pre-registered specification”, 29 October 2026, https://tipsheet.markets/research/sip_studies_spec/"
---

[Pre-registered research](https://tipsheet.markets/research/)

# SIP studies: pre-registered specification

Written 2026-10-02 by lane 2, **before any SIP result was computed**. The engine, costs and tax rules are those of the portfolio lab v2 (`portfolio_lab_v2_spec.md`, sections 3, 7 and 8 and Appendix B) and the library (`portfolio_library.md`). Changes after this date go under “Amendments” with the date and the reason.

## 1. Questions

1. For each portfolio in the library, what range of after-tax returns did a monthly SIP deliver over 3, 5, 7, 10, 15 and 20 years, depending on when it started?
2. How often did a SIP do worse than the same instalments put in bank fixed deposits, and worse than inflation?
3. Do the popular SIP refinements (step-ups, a lucky date of the month, valuation-aware amounts, STPs) change the outcome, and what does stopping a SIP in a crash cost?
4. Can I reproduce published Indian SIP studies, and where I differ, why?

## 2. Pre-registered predictions (graded in the results log)

- **S1.** The SIP date of the month makes no practical difference: the median after-tax XIRR across start months differs by less than 0.2 percentage points between any two dates, and no difference is significant once overlap is accounted for.
- **S2.** An all-equity (Nifty 500) SIP had a lower after-tax XIRR than the fixed-deposit SIP in some 5-year windows but in no 15-year window.
- **S3.** The valuation-aware dynamic SIP beats the plain SIP by less than 0.5 points of XIRR at the median 10-year window, with the interval for the difference including zero.
- **S4.** Pausing during drawdowns lowers the terminal value relative to an uninterrupted SIP in most windows that contain a drawdown of more than 20%.
- **S5.** Lump sum beats a 12-month STP in about two thirds of start months for an all-equity portfolio, in line with the US finding of Vanguard (2012, “Dollar-cost averaging just means taking risk later”).

## 3. The plain SIP

- **Instalment:** Rs 10,000 a month, bought at the close of the first NSE session on or after the 1st of each month (the date-of-month study varies this).
- **Portfolio:** every portfolio in the lab v2 library (sections 5.1 to 5.7 of its spec), with its own rebalancing rule. For multi-asset portfolios, each instalment goes first to the sleeves furthest below target (cash-flow rebalancing); the portfolio’s scheduled rebalancing still runs. For tactical rules, instalments follow the current target weights.
- **Costs and tax:** as in the lab spec, including stamp duty on each instalment from July 2020. Every instalment is its own tax lot (FIFO). Tax on gains realised by rebalancing is paid each financial year from the portfolio.
- **Exit:** the whole portfolio is redeemed at the end of the window, and that year’s tax is settled. The after-tax XIRR uses the instalments as outflows and the after-tax redemption value as the inflow. I also report the pre-tax XIRR and the value before redemption.
- **Equity exemption:** the annual long-term exemption (Rs 1 lakh from FY2018-19, Rs 1.25 lakh from FY2024-25) is **on** in the headline SIP results, because a Rs 10,000 SIP investor is the small investor the exemption is meant for, and off in a sensitivity run. (The lab’s lump-sum results, which are scale-free, keep it off.)

## 4. Windows and overlap

- **Horizons:** 3, 5, 7, 10, 15 and 20 years (36 to 240 instalments; the window ends one month after the last instalment).
- **Start months:** every month from the portfolio’s first usable month to the last month that leaves a full horizon. “First usable” means every asset it holds exists and its rule has finished warming up.
- **Two views:**
  
  - *Common starts* from April 2005, for comparing portfolios on the same windows.
  - *Longest history* for the portfolios that allow more (all-equity Nifty 50 from July 1999, Nifty 500 from 1995, and the n500 / G-sec / gold mixes from about 2002).
- **Overlap:** windows that start a month apart share almost all their months, so the many windows are far from independent. For each horizon I state the number of non-overlapping windows that fit in the sample (the effective number of independent periods) next to every statistic. Percentiles across start months are descriptions of history, not probabilities; I do not attach confidence intervals that treat overlapping windows as independent. Where I compare two SIP variants, I test the mean of the paired differences with a Newey-West standard error with lags equal to the horizon in months, and I also report the result on the non-overlapping subsample.

## 5. What is reported for each portfolio and horizon

- The distribution of after-tax XIRR across start months: 5th, 10th, 25th, 50th, 75th, 90th and 95th percentiles, the worst and best with their start months, and the mean.
- **Share of windows below fixed deposits:** the after-tax XIRR of the SIP against the after-tax XIRR of the same instalments placed in one-year fixed deposits rolled over each year, with interest taxed each year at 30% plus cess. The FD rate is the scheduled commercial banks’ deposit rate for more than one year (maximum, RBI, weekly) where available; until lane 1 adds it to the warehouse, and before November 2011 in any case, the 364-day T-bill primary yield, and the 91-day yield before the 364-day series starts. The proxy is stated wherever the result appears.
- **Share of windows below inflation:** the real after-tax XIRR (each cash flow deflated by the all-India CPI of its month) is below zero.
- **What Rs 10,000 a month became:** for each start month, the after-tax value at the end in rupees, and in rupees of the window’s final month (CPI-deflated), with the total invested.
- Pre-tax XIRR and the tax drag.

## 6. Variants

Run on a headline set of 12 portfolios: `n50`, `n500`, `mid150`, `small250`, `sixty_forty`, `sixty_twenty_twenty`, `equal_thirds`, `permanent`, `all_weather`, `gtaa`, `dual_momentum`, `factor_four`.

| Variant | Rule |
| --- | --- |
| SIP against lump sum | For each start month and horizon, the SIP’s XIRR against the CAGR of investing the same total at the start. This is the comparison people usually make, but the two are not alternatives for the same investor; the STP study below is the fair one. |
| Step-up SIP | Instalment grows 5% (and 10%) each year on the anniversary of the first instalment. |
| Date of month | First session on or after the 1st, 5th, 10th, 15th, 20th, 25th and 28th. Paired against the 1st. |
| Dynamic SIP (valuation-aware) | Cash-neutral: the investor sets aside Rs 10,000 a month. The amount invested is 1.5× when the Sensex CAPE10 (IIMA, previous month-end) is at or below its expanding 33rd percentile, 1× in the middle, and 0.5× at or above the 67th percentile. Money not invested waits in the liquid sleeve (taxed as a liquid fund), which funds the 1.5× months; if it runs short, only what is there is invested. Everything, including the buffer, counts at the end. A second version uses the Nifty 500 earnings yield minus the 10-year G-sec yield. Applied to `n50` and `n500` only. |
| STP from liquid to equity | A lump sum of Rs 12 lakh starts in the liquid sleeve and moves to the equity portfolio in 6 (and 12) equal monthly transfers, against investing it all on day one. Compared at 1, 3, 5 and 10 years. Equity portfolios in the headline set only. |
| Pausing in drawdowns (the behaviour gap) | The SIP stops when the Nifty 500 is more than 20% below its previous peak at a month-end and restarts when the drawdown is back above −10%. Two behaviours: (a) the skipped instalments stay in the liquid sleeve, never invested in equity; (b) the backlog is invested in one go on restart. Both against the uninterrupted SIP. |
| Exemption off | Section 3’s exemption switched off. |

## 7. Replication checks

The engine is run in a “replication mode” (no costs, no tax, the published index) and compared with these published studies:

| Study | What they report | My closest reproduction | Expected differences |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Freefincal (Pattabiraman 2020): Nifty 50 TRI, Jul 1999 to Jan 2020 | 10-year rolling SIP XIRR fell from above 20% (2009 endings) to about 10% (2020 endings) | Nifty 50 TRI, same dates, 10-year rolling XIRR by end month | instalment date conventions |
| WhiteOak Capital (2024): Sensex TRI, Sep 1996 to May 2024 | minimum SIP XIRR 4.6% at 10 years, 7.4% at 15; 79% / 90% of windows above 12% at 10 / 15 years | Nifty 50 TRI from Jul 1999 (I do not hold the Sensex TRI) | different index and a shorter sample: I expect the same shape, not the same numbers |
| Geojit (2024): Sensex, Sep 1996 to Jul 2024 | 10-year median 14.3%, minimum 4.1%; 15-year median 14.3%, minimum 7.0% | as above | as above, and Geojit does not say whether it used the TRI |

A reproduction counts as a match when the same index and dates give a median within 0.5 points and a minimum within 1 point. Where the index differs, I report both and explain the gap; I do not tune anything to close it. A study whose numbers I cannot reproduce on the same index is reported as such.

## 8. Outputs

Derived tables `.cache/derived/sip_*.parquet` and bundles under `lab/sip/*`, documented in `FRONTEND_HANDOFF.md` (lane 2 section): the outcome distributions by portfolio and horizon, the per-start-month XIRR series for the explorer, and one table per variant.

## 9. Known limits

- The FD comparison uses a T-bill proxy until deposit-rate data lands.
- 20-year windows exist only for starts up to about 2006, so the 20-year results rest on very few independent periods (one or two).
- Index funds on mid caps, small caps and factors did not exist for most of the sample; those SIPs are hypothetical before the funds launched.

## Amendments

**2026-10-07 (owner’s request, after results): showcase portfolios and two descriptive views.** These add description only; no prediction (S1-S5) is regraded and nothing in sections 3-6 changes.

- New asset: Nifty LargeMidcap 250 TRI (`lm250`; base 2005-04-01, launched 2017-11-30 per its NSE factsheet; back-tested before that, cost class `broad_small`). New portfolios: `lm250` (buy and hold) and four fixed four-asset mixes of `lm250`, `small250`, `gold` and `gsec5`, rebalanced each January: `ma_equal` (25 each) and `ma_80`, `ma_60`, `ma_40` (equity 80/60/40%, split three parts large-mid to one part small; gold and G-sec equal halves of the rest). The weights are round and were fixed before any result for them was seen; none were tuned. They also enter the portfolio lab library, so the lab’s trial count rises by five.
- Showcase set (`lab/sip.py: SHOWCASE`): Nifty 50, 100, 500, LargeMidcap 250, Midcap 150, Smallcap 250, gold alone, G-sec alone, 60/40, 60/20/20, equal thirds and the four mixes. Each gets a before-tax run (`taxed=False`, costs still on) beside the after-tax one.
- To-date view: for the showcase set, a SIP started in each month from 2005-04 to twelve months before the last session, valued at the last session as if sold that day (after tax, and before tax). This is the figure investors see, and it is unsettled for recent starts; it is shown as a picture of where SIPs stand, not as a distribution.

**2026-10-08 (owner’s request): the second set of studies, written before any of them was computed.** Code: `lab/sip_more.py`; bundles `lab/sip/pain`, `lab/sip/timing`, `lab/sip/amount`, `lab/sip/years`. Rs 10,000 a month on the first session of each month unless stated; common starts from 2005-04.

*Definitions.*

- **Statement value:** the SIP’s market value after fund costs, before tax and before selling, at each month-end. It is what a fund statement shows, so the pain studies use it.
- **Under water:** statement value below the money put in so far. **Below FD:** below what the same instalments would be worth in the FD proxy. **Below inflation:** below the instalments grown by CPI.
- **Stretch:** consecutive month-ends in one of those states, for one start month; the longest stretch is over the SIP’s whole life to the last session (recent starts are censored and marked so).
- **Head to head:** for each horizon, the share of common start months in which one portfolio’s after-tax XIRR was below another’s (gold alone, G-sec alone, the FD SIP), from the plain windows.
- **Dip buying, the fair version:** each Rs 10,000 goes into the liquid fund (cash) on the usual date; the whole cash balance moves into the portfolio’s equity index on the first session after a qualifying signal. Signals: a one-day fall of at least 1%, 2% or 3% in that index; or a month-end with it 10% or 20% below its peak (on the next session). Cash still waiting at the end counts in the final value. No extra money is added: a dip buyer who adds money ends with more only because more went in. Run on Nifty 50, Nifty 500 and Smallcap 250, every horizon, after tax, paired with the plain SIP.
- **Weekly SIP:** Rs 10,000 x 12 / 52 on the first session of each week, against the monthly SIP, same portfolios.
- **Starting at a high:** the plain windows grouped by how far the portfolio’s equity index was below its all-time high at the first instalment: within 2%, 2-10%, 10-20%, more than 20%.
- **Step-up:** instalments raised 5%, 10% or 15% each year; total invested, median final value (also in today’s rupees) and median XIRR, against no step-up.
- **Delay:** from the longest-history Nifty 500 view, the median corpus of 10-, 15- and 20-year SIPs, and the monthly amount a 15-year SIP would need to match the 20-year median.
- **Direct and regular plans:** the Nifty 500 SIP with an extra running cost of 0.5% and 1.0% a year (the usual gap between direct and regular plans of index and active funds), against the direct-plan cost schedule.
- **Calendar years:** for each year and portfolio, a SIP started in that January (twelve instalments) and valued at the year’s last session. *SIP return* is the gain divided by the average money invested over the year (Modified Dietz), not an annualised XIRR, which would turn a December instalment’s one-month move into an annual rate. *Worst point* is the deepest the statement value fell below the money put in so far, within the year.

*Predictions.*

- **S6.** Every dip-buying rule trails the plain SIP at the median 10-year window for the Nifty 50 and Nifty 500 (median paired difference below zero for each signal).
- **S7.** A weekly SIP’s median 10-year after-tax XIRR is within 0.1 point of the monthly SIP’s for every portfolio tested.
- **S8.** Nifty 500 SIPs started within 2% of an all-time high had a median 10-year XIRR within 1.5 points of those started 10% or more below it.
- **S9.** Between no step-up and a 15% step-up, the median 10-year Nifty 500 XIRR changes by less than 0.5 point, while the median final value rises by more than 50%.
- **S10.** More than half of all Nifty 500 SIPs (by start month) were under water at some month-end, and none was still under water five years after it started.
- **S11.** A 10-year Nifty 500 SIP had a lower after-tax XIRR than the same SIP in gold in more than a quarter of common start months.
- **S12.** An extra 1% a year of running cost leaves a 15-year Nifty 500 SIP with a median final value 8% to 12% lower.

**2026-10-08 (owner’s request): study A, the long history from 1995, measured data only. Written before any of it was computed.** Code: `lab/sip_long.py`; bundle `lab/sip/long`; page `/lab/sip/long/`; methods note `docs/methods/long_history.md`.

*Series.*

- **Equity:** Nifty 500 TRI from January 1995; Nifty 50 TRI from June 1999. No assumptions: both are published total-return indices.
- **Debt:** the synthetic 10-year constant-maturity G-sec (`synthetic_gsec10`, Swinkels 2019) from the month-end 10-year yield (May 1996 on), as in the lab. Mixes holding it start in June 1996.
- **Gold:** RBI’s monthly average domestic price in Mumbai (Rs per 10 grams, via India Data Hub `MOINGOINRS11M`, from April 1990), linked by ratio to the lab’s gold at June 2005, where the lab’s series becomes WGC’s domestic rupee price. Monthly averages are placed mid-month and filled between by constant daily growth. Before 2005 the lab’s own gold is USD gold times USD/INR and misses import-duty changes: against RBI’s domestic price it drifts by about 9% between 2000 and 2004, so RBI’s series is preferred for those years.
- **Costs and tax:** the lab’s schedules by date. Index funds, gilt funds and gold ETFs did not all exist in the 1990s; their costs stand in for what an investor could have paid. The Cost Inflation Index now covers FY1995-96 to FY2000-01 (old 1981 base, rebased to 2001-02 = 100: 66.0, 71.6, 77.7, 82.4, 91.3, 95.3); before this amendment the lab used the FY2001-02 value for earlier purchases, which under-indexed them. Surcharges of the late 1990s are not modelled.

*Portfolios.* Nifty 500, Nifty 50, gold alone, the synthetic G-sec alone, 60/40 (Nifty 500 / G-sec), 60/20/20 and equal thirds (with gold), rebalanced each January. Plain SIP, after tax, horizons 3 to 20 years; the to-date paths of the pain studies as well.

*Validation, with pass marks set now.* (1) Gold join: correlation of monthly log changes between RBI’s series and the lab’s from 2005 at least 0.95 (it was 0.96 over 2000-2025 before any study result; input check). (2) Synthetic G-sec against the NSE 5-year G-sec index, 2001 on: correlation of monthly returns at least 0.8, and the synthetic’s higher volatility consistent with its longer duration. Both are reported on the page whatever they show.

*Predictions.*

- **S13.** The median 10-year Nifty 500 SIP XIRR differs by more than 8 points between the best and the worst start year from 1995 to 2016.
- **S14.** In at least one start year from 1996 to 2016, the median 10-year Nifty 500 SIP had a lower after-tax XIRR than the synthetic G-sec SIP.
- **S15.** The longest stretch a Nifty 500 SIP started from 1995 spent below the money put in is longer than three years (the longest for starts from 2005 was 23 months).
- **S16.** Over all start months from 1995, a 10-year Nifty 500 SIP beat the same SIP in gold in more than two thirds of windows.

**2026-10-08 (owner’s request): the FD rate as section 5 names it, written before the rerun.** Section 5 named banks’ deposit rate for terms over one year as the FD rate, with the 364-day T-bill “until lane 1 adds it to the warehouse”. It was never added, and the verification sweep of 2026-10-08 measured the proxy’s gap: banks’ 1-3 year rate (top of RBI’s range) averaged 1.33 points above it over FY1993-FY2010 (4.17 in 1997-98), and RBI’s weekly rate over one year (maximum) 0.76 points above it over 2012-2026. The FD rate is now (`lab/deposit_rates.py`):

- FY1975-76 to FY1995-96: the administered 1-3 year deposit rate, RBI Handbook of Statistics 2009-10, Table 74, constant through each financial year;
- end-March 1997 to end-March 2010, and July 2010: the 1-3 year rate of five major public sector banks at each date, top of the range (same table), joined by straight lines;
- from November 2011: RBI’s weekly deposit rate of scheduled commercial banks for terms over one year, maximum (India Data Hub `MOIRCBDRMX11W`), with a straight line from July 2010;
- the T-bill proxy only where none of these covers a date (until the weekly series reaches the warehouse), recorded in each bundle’s `meta.fd` and stated on the pages. The money still accrues daily at the rate known the day before, interest taxed each year at slab plus cess: an approximation to one-year deposits rolled each year. All three studies are rerun; every graded prediction that compares against FDs (S2, S10’s FD measures, the pain and long pages) is regraded with this rate, and the earlier grade is kept in the log.

**The 10-year G-sec is NSE’s index from 2001 (owner decision, 2026-10-09, after results).** The lab’s `gsec10`, which these studies use, is now NSE’s Nifty 10 yr Benchmark G-Sec (total return) from its base date, 2 January 2001: the niftyindices history the Data bank holds, and Kite’s copy of the same index for 2001-2010 and for days missing from ours (Kite matches NSE on 3,840 shared days; a bad stretch in November 2015 and one day in June 2024 take NSE’s values, and one Kite-only spike, 12 March 2009, is rebuilt from the days either side). Before 2001 the bond rebuilt from yields stays, scaled to meet NSE’s first value. Rules and checks: `clean_gs10` and `gsec10_series` in `pipeline/tipsheet/lab/universe.py`; Kite’s raw series is kept unedited in `pipeline/tipsheet/reference/kite_nifty_gs_10yr.csv`. Why: the rebuilt bond is a theoretical one: always exactly ten years to run, priced at the curve’s 10-year yield. NSE’s index holds the actual benchmark bond, which a gilt fund can buy. The rebuilt bond ran 0.8 points a year above it over 2001-2010 and 1.6 points over 2011-2025 (monthly correlation 0.95 and 0.75). Its daily tail, FBIL’s par yield through India Data Hub, also posts a session or two after NSE. All three studies are rerun. S14 now reads “the G-sec SIP” for “the synthetic G-sec SIP” and is regraded; every earlier grade stays in the log. Mixes holding the G-sec still start in June 1996, on the rebuilt bond until 2001.

**2026-10-09 (owner’s request): study B, the reference view, written before any of it was computed.** The owner asked for the SIP pages to be rebuilt as a reference: every holding period from 1 to 20 years, comparisons with G-sec and gold as well as FDs, real returns, and whether SIP returns have fallen with the decade the SIP started in, back to the Sensex’s first year. Code: `lab/sip_ref.py`; bundle `lab/sip/ref`.

*Every holding period.* The plain SIP of section 3, after tax, at every whole horizon from 1 to 20 years, for (a) the long-history portfolios of study A from their first start month and (b) the showcase set from 2005-04. Nothing else in sections 3 to 5 changes. Start months are those that leave the full horizon, so the 1-year rows have the most windows and the 20-year rows the fewest.

*The Sensex from 1979, index level.*

- **Price:** BSE’s daily Sensex closes from 3 April 1979 (the Data bank’s BSE index archive), never published as levels.
- **Total return, rebuilt, from January 1991:** each day’s price return plus the previous day’s published dividend yield accrued for the days elapsed. BSE publishes no Sensex TRI before 1999 in any source I hold. Its archive carries a dividend yield of exactly zero on every day from 1979 to 1990 (a placeholder, not a measurement); the first real value is in 1991. No yield is assumed for the 1980s, so the total-return Sensex starts in the first month with a measured yield, and the decade question from 1979 is answered on the price index. (Found while checking inputs, before any SIP result was computed; the predictions below were rewritten to match on the same day.) Before any Sensex result was computed, the same rebuild applied to the Nifty 50 (NSE price index and NSE’s dividend yield, June 1999 to October 2026) gave a CAGR of 12.96% against NSE’s published TRI at 12.89%, a monthly correlation of 0.9998 and calendar-year gaps between −0.68 and +0.61 points (median +0.03). Pass mark for the Sensex rebuild, set now: from 2001, its monthly returns correlate with the Nifty 50 TRI’s at 0.97 or more and its CAGR is within 1 point of it. Reported whatever it shows.
- **SIP:** Rs 10,000 on the first session of each month, no costs and no tax (no index fund existed before 2001, so there is no honest cost or tax history to apply), every horizon from 1 to 20 years, price and total-return versions.
- **Comparisons:** the same instalments in fixed deposits at section 5’s deposit rate, before tax, to match. Real XIRR deflates each flow by CPI: the site’s all-India CPI from October 1988, and before that the OECD’s India consumer price index (FRED `INDCPIALLMINMEI`, which follows CPI for industrial workers), linked by the ratio at October 1988.
- **Start decade:** windows grouped by the calendar decade of the first instalment (1979-89 counted as the 1980s). Recent decades have fewer full windows at long horizons, and the 2010s have no 15- or 20-year windows; each figure states its count of windows and independent periods.
- **Paths:** for each start month, the longest stretch the statement value spent below the money put in, below the FD SIP, and below the instalments grown by CPI (study A’s definitions).

*Predictions.*

- **S17.** The median 10-year SIP XIRR on the price-only Sensex of 1980s starts exceeds that of 2010s starts (to 2016) by more than 5 points.
- **S18.** On the total-return Sensex, the median 10-year SIP XIRR of 1990s starts (from 1991) exceeds that of 2010s starts by more than 2 points.
- **S19.** In real terms the gap in S17 is less than half the nominal gap, because inflation fell over the same decades.
- **S20.** At the median 10-year window from 1991, the rebuilt total return adds between 1 and 2 points a year to the Sensex SIP’s XIRR over the price index.
- **S21.** At least one 10-year SIP on the price-only Sensex started from 1979 had a negative real XIRR.
- **S22.** For each equity portfolio in the long-history set, the share of start months with an after-tax XIRR below zero is under 5% by the 7-year horizon.

## Results log

### 2026-10-09: study B, the reference view (S17-S22; data to 2026-10-07, Sensex to 2026-10-01)

**Inputs.** The Sensex total-return rebuild passed its pass mark: monthly correlation with the Nifty 50 TRI from 2001 of 0.993 (mark 0.97) and a CAGR gap of 0.11 points (mark 1). The CPI link at October 1988 joins the OECD series to the site’s at a ratio of 0.657; over 426 overlapping months their year-on-year rates correlate at 0.963.

**Predictions.**

- **S17 holds.** Price-only Sensex, median 10-year SIP XIRR: 23.0% for 1979-89 starts against 12.6% for 2010s starts, a gap of 10.4 points.
- **S18 fails, in the other direction.** With dividends, 2010s starts (14.0%) beat 1990s starts (12.8%). Since 1990 the ten-year median has not declined; the spread between start months has narrowed.
- **S19 fails, narrowly.** The real gap between 1979-89 and 2010s starts is 5.5 points, against half the nominal gap, 5.2. Falling inflation explains a little under half of the fall.
- **S20 holds.** Dividends added a median 1.54 points a year to the ten-year Sensex SIP from 1991.
- **S21 holds.** The worst real 10-year XIRR on the price-only Sensex was −9.9%, for a SIP started in October 1991.
- **S22 holds.** Share of 7-year SIPs below zero after tax: Nifty 50 0.0%, Nifty 500 2.4%.

**Other results.** At fifteen years the price-only Sensex medians fall every decade (16.9%, 14.2%, 12.2%, 11.7%; the last on 22 start months). A Sensex SIP started in February 1992 spent 125 months in a row behind the same money in FDs on the price index (59 months with dividends). 97% of Sensex SIPs since 1979 were under water at some month-end; the deepest, a SIP started in October 2007, was 48% below the money put in on 27 October 2008.

### 2026-10-09: rerun on NSE’s 10-year G-sec (all three studies; data to 2026-10-06)

- **S14 still failed, by more.** No start year from 1996 to 2016 had a median 10-year Nifty 500 SIP behind the G-sec SIP. The closest is still 2010: 9.3% against 6.7% after tax (was 8.5% on the rebuilt bond).
- The G-sec SIP’s median 10-year after-tax XIRR over starts from 1996 to 2016 fell from 7.0% to 5.6%; the 60/40’s from 11.7% to 11.0%. Equity and gold lines are unchanged.
- The bond check against NSE’s 5-year index (pass mark 0.8) now reads a monthly correlation of 0.87 over 301 months (was 0.83 for the rebuilt bond).

### 2026-10-08: rerun with the FD rate from RBI deposit rates (all three studies)

The FD rate is now banks’ deposit rate (amendment above), with no stretch on the T-bill proxy (`meta.fd.proxy_used_from` is empty; the weekly series was fetched from India Data Hub for this local run, as the warehouse will hold it). Median after-tax FD XIRR of a 10-year SIP: 5.2% (was 4.6%). Changes in the FD comparisons; nothing else moves:

- Nifty 500 SIP below FD, from 2005: 3 years 22.9% (was 21.1%), 5 years 11.6% (8.0%), 10 years 0.7% (0.7%), 15 years 0% (0%).
- From 1995: Nifty 500 at 5 years 18.1% (15.3%), 10 years 0.4% (0.4%); gold at 10 years 15.3% (12.6%); synthetic G-sec at 10 years 11.4% (0%).
- **S2 still holds**: below FD in 11.6% of 5-year windows and in no 15-year window.
- The longest stretch below FDs for a Nifty 500 SIP from 2005 is 38 months (was 25).

### 2026-10-08: study A, from 1995 (S13-S16; data to 2026-10-06)

`lab/sip_long.py`, 178 s: 10,260 windows and 2,536 to-date paths over seven portfolios. Validation passed both pre-set marks: the gold join’s monthly changes correlated 0.964 with the lab’s gold from June 2005 (mark 0.95); the synthetic 10-year G-sec’s monthly returns correlated 0.834 with NSE’s 5-year G-sec index from October 2001 (mark 0.80), 7.98% a year against 7.80%, volatility 6.8% against 3.8%.

- **S13 held.** Median 10-year Nifty 500 XIRR by start year: 25.3% (1997) to 9.3% (2010), a 16-point spread.
- **S14 failed.** No start year’s median Nifty 500 SIP trailed the synthetic G-sec’s; the closest was 2010 (9.3% against 8.5%), when 42% of start months did trail.
- **S15 held.** Longest stretch under water: 38 months, from an August 1999 start.
- **S16 held.** The Nifty 500 beat gold in 77% of 10-year windows from 1995; gold won most starts in 2002, 2003, 2015 and 2016.

### 2026-10-08: the second set (S6-S12; data to 2026-10-06)

`lab/sip_more.py`, 199 s on 14 cores: 3,855 to-date paths (15 portfolios x every start month to 2026-09), 8,415 dip-rule windows, 2,805 weekly windows, 10,008 step-up windows at 15%, 1,668 regular-plan windows. Bundles `lab/sip/pain`, `timing`, `amount`, `years`; pages under `/lab/sip/`.

- **S6 failed.** Daily-fall rules all trailed the plain SIP at the median 10-year window (Nifty 500: 1% fall -0.06, 2% -0.29, 3% -0.09 points). The peak-to-trough rules did not: waiting for a 20% fall finished +0.73 (Nifty 500) and +1.00 (Nifty 50) ahead, waiting for 10% +0.03 and +0.17. They rest on two episodes (2008 and 2020) and the median window ended with Rs 4.8 lakh (Nifty 500) still in cash; the Newey-West t is not testable at this overlap.
- **S7 held.** Weekly minus monthly at 10 years: at most +0.05 points (Nifty 500 +0.054, Smallcap 250 +0.054); at 3 years up to +0.17.
- **S8 held.** Nifty 500 10-year median: 12.3% for starts within 2% of a high, 12.6% for starts 10% or more below (33 and 71 windows).
- **S9 held.** Nifty 500 10-year median XIRR 12.75% with no step-up, 12.92% at 15%; median final value Rs 23.3 lakh to Rs 41.6 lakh (+78%).
- **S10 half held.** 96% of start months with a year of history were under water at some month-end; at five years 1.5% still were (starts Jan 2007, Apr and Jun 2015), so the second half failed.
- **S11 failed.** A 10-year Nifty 500 SIP lost to gold in 17% of start months (24 of 139: Mar 2006 and starts from 2010 to 2016, windows ending in gold’s recent run-up); 41% at 5 years.
- **S12 held.** An extra 1% a year cost 8.7% of the median 15-year final value (11.9% at 20 years; 0.5% a year cost 4.5% at 15).

### 2026-10-02: first run (starts April 2005 to September 2023; data to 2026-09-30)

136 portfolios × up to 222 start months × six horizons: 112,608 SIP windows, plus the variants and the longest-history view. Code: `pipeline/tipsheet/lab/sip.py`; tables `.cache/derived/sip_*`; bundles `lab/sip/*`. All XIRRs are after costs and tax, on full redemption at the end of the window, with the equity exemption on. The FD hurdle is the 364-day T-bill proxy (deposit-rate data not yet in the warehouse), after 30% tax and cess each year: its median after-tax yield was 4.5% to 4.9% depending on the horizon. “Independent periods” is the number of non-overlapping windows that fit in the sample; percentiles describe history and are not probabilities.

**The plain SIP (Rs 10,000 a month), common starts from April 2005.**

| Portfolio | Horizon | Independent periods | 5th pct | Median | Worst (start) | Below FD | Below inflation |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Nifty 500 | 5 years | 4 | 3.9 | 13.5 | −6.1 (2015-04) | 8.1% | 20.2% |
| Nifty 500 | 10 years | 2 | 9.1 | 12.8 | 3.4 (2010-04) | 0.7% | 0.7% |
| Nifty 500 | 15 years | 1 | 8.9 | 12.9 | 6.1 (2005-04) | 0% | 1.3% |
| Nifty 50 | 10 years | 2 | 8.5 | 12.0 | 3.4 (2010-04) | 0.7% | 1.4% |
| Smallcap 250 | 5 years | 4 | −2.9 | 16.7 | −17.8 (2015-04) | 23.2% | 28.3% |
| Smallcap 250 | 10 years | 2 | 6.7 | 14.5 | −1.1 (2010-04) | 2.9% | 3.6% |
| 60/40 | 5 years | 4 | 5.5 | 11.2 | 0.6 (2015-04) | 3.5% | 19.7% |
| 60/40 | 10 years | 2 | 9.0 | 10.9 | 5.9 (2010-04) | 0% | 0% |
| 60/20/20 | 5 years | 4 | 7.4 | 11.4 | 1.1 (2015-04) | 1.5% | 11.1% |
| Equal thirds | 5 years | 4 | 6.6 | 10.5 | 4.5 (2015-04) | 0.5% | 7.6% |
| Permanent | 5 years | 4 | 6.6 | 9.3 | 4.7 (2015-04) | 0% | 7.1% |
| GTAA | 10 years | 2 | 5.7 | 7.8 | 5.4 (2009-08) | 0% | 0% |
| 100% G-sec | 5 years | 4 | 5.0 | 6.4 | 4.7 (2018-11) | 0% | 44.9% |

- **Equity SIPs had a wide spread over 3 to 5 years and a narrow one at 10 to 15.** The worst windows cluster on the same calendar: SIPs started in April 2010 and redeemed in the March-April 2020 crash were the worst 10-year outcome for every equity-heavy portfolio, and SIPs started in April 2015 and redeemed in 2020 the worst 5-year ones.
- **Multi-asset mixes shrank the bad tail far more than the median.** At five years, 60/20/20’s 5th percentile was 7.4% against the Nifty 500’s 3.9%, for a median 2 points lower. Equal thirds and the permanent portfolio never did worse than the FD proxy at 5 years or more except in one window, but beat inflation by less.
- **Twenty-year results rest on 18 start months** (April 2005 to September 2006): one independent period. They are shown, but say almost nothing about the next 20 years.
- **Longest history (Nifty 500 from 1995, Nifty 50 from 1999):** the 10-year Nifty 500 SIP had a median of 13.8% and a worst of 3.4% across 260 windows (three independent periods); the 20-year median was 14.0% with a worst of 10.7% (140 windows, one independent period).

**Variants (headline set of 12 portfolios).**

- **Date of month: not a null.** SIPs dated the 20th, 25th or 28th beat those dated the 1st in most windows, by a median of up to 0.75 points of XIRR at 3 years (mid and small caps), 0.2 to 0.45 at 5 years and under 0.21 at 10 years. The gain shrinks roughly as one over the horizon, which is what a fixed price advantage per instalment produces. The source is a turn-of-month effect in Indian indices: from the 25th to the next 1st, the Nifty 500 TRI rose 0.85% on average (2005-2026) against 0.26% expected from its average daily drift (t = 5.2; Midcap 150 1.16%, t = 7.1). Days 5 to 15 differ from the 1st by at most 0.14 points at any horizon.
- **Step-ups** (5% and 10% a year) barely move the XIRR (the Nifty 500 10-year median stays at 12.8%) but raise the final corpus, by about a fifth at 10 years for a 10% step-up, because more money is invested.
- **SIP against lump sum.** At 5 and 10 years, for equity portfolios the SIP’s XIRR beat the lump sum’s CAGR in 54% to 67% of windows (the range is wider, 22% to 89%, at 3, 15 and 20 years, where windows are fewer) (Nifty 500 at 10 years: median gap +0.6 points). For multi-asset portfolios it was a coin toss. As the spec says, this compares two different investors.
- **STP against lump sum** (Rs 12 lakh). Investing all of it on day one beat a 12-month STP in 59% to 70% of start months, and beat a 6-month STP in 58% to 64%. At the median a 12-month STP ended 3% to 7% poorer, depending on the asset and horizon.
- **Valuation-aware dynamic SIP: it lost.** Investing 1.5× when the CAPE was in its cheapest third and 0.5× in its dearest, with the difference parked in a liquid fund, lowered the median 10-year XIRR by 0.26 points (CAPE) and 1.3 points (yield gap) against the plain SIP, and ended with Rs 0.4 lakh to Rs 1.5 lakh less at 10 years. The CAPE was in its dearest third in 61% of months from 2014, so the rule kept money in the liquid fund through a rising market.
- **Pausing in drawdowns cost money in almost every window.** Stopping when the Nifty 500 fell 20% below its peak and restarting when it recovered to −10%, with the skipped money left in a liquid fund, cut the 10-year XIRR by 1.5 points at the median and the corpus by about Rs 1.8 lakh on Rs 12 lakh invested; the uninterrupted SIP won in more than 99% of 10-year windows. Investing the backlog on restart halved the damage but never removed it.
- **Tax.** Tax cost the plain SIP 0.4 to 0.6 points of XIRR at 10 years for buy-and-hold and static portfolios, and 1.1 to 1.4 for GTAA and dual momentum. The equity exemption was worth only 0.04 to 0.09 points at 10 years: the final redemption is one large sale in one year.

**Replication (Nifty 50 TRI, no costs, no tax, instalment on the first session of each month from July 1999).**

| Horizon | Windows | Min | Median | Share above 12% |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| 10 years | 207 | 3.9% | 13.7% | 73% |
| 15 years | 147 | 6.9% | 13.4% | 86% |
| 20 years | 87 | 10.9% | 13.6% | 91% |

- **Freefincal (Nifty 50 TRI):** reproduced. My 10-year SIP ending December 2009 returned 21.5% and the one ending January 2020 11.6%; theirs fell from above 20% to about 10% over the same endings. The April 2020 ending gives 3.8%.
- **WhiteOak (Sensex TRI from 1996; 10-year minimum 4.6%, 15-year 7.4%, 79% and 90% above 12%) and Geojit (Sensex; 10-year median 14.3%, minimum 4.1%; 15-year median 14.3%, minimum 7.0%):** same shape, slightly lower numbers. The differences are what I expected: a different index, a sample that starts in 1999 instead of 1996 (missing the strong 1996-99 starts) and ends in 2026 instead of 2024 (adding the weak 2024-26 endings). I did not tune anything to close the gap. On the same index and dates I could not test them, so neither counts as a match under section 7.

**Predictions.**

- **S1 fails.** The date of the month mattered more than 0.2 points at horizons up to 5 years (late-month dates better), through a genuine turn-of-month effect. At 10 years and beyond it is under 0.21 points. Two cautions: I tested six dates on twelve portfolios and six horizons, and an effect this well known (Ariel 1987; Lakonishok and Smidt 1988) may weaken now it is visible. Fund houses also apply the NAV of the day the money is realised, which can shift a “25th” SIP by a day or two.
- **S2 holds.** The Nifty 500 SIP fell below the FD proxy in 8.1% of 5-year windows and in none of the 15-year windows.
- **S3 fails in the other direction.** The dynamic SIP did not beat the plain SIP at all; it lost 0.26 points (CAPE) and 1.3 points (yield gap) at the median 10-year window.
- **S4 holds.** Pausing lowered the terminal value in nearly every window that contained a 20% drawdown.
- **S5 holds.** Lump sum beat a 12-month STP in about two thirds of start months (59% to 70%).

### 2026-10-03: audit corrections (register rows L21–L24, V3, V7, D4); rules unchanged

- **Newey-West t-values (L21):** the paired tests used a Newey-West t with lags equal to the horizon in months even when there were fewer windows than lags. Values of 38 and 73 were published; with these sizes an AR(1) null rejects 53% of the time at a nominal 5%.
  
  - **Where n is too small:** the t is now published only where the windows number at least three times the lag. At 7 years and beyond, the non-overlapping columns are the evidence.
  - **Where it is published:** it comes with the fixed-b critical value `t_crit_fixed_b` (Kiefer and Vogelsang 2005; 2.45 to 2.88 here), not 1.96.
- **S1 (date of month): fails, unchanged.** At 3 and 5 years, 50 of 144 date comparisons exceed their fixed-b critical value (62 exceeded 2 before). The effect is the turn-of-month return (late-month dates better by up to 0.48 points at 3 years). Beyond 5 years there is no valid t, and the non-overlapping differences are under 0.2 points.
- **S3 (dynamic SIP): fails in the other direction, by more.** The yield-gap signal now uses the consolidated P/E from a maintained table (V3, V7).
  
  - Yield-gap dynamic SIP at the median 10-year window: **−1.57 points** (Nifty 500; was −1.30) and **−1.43** (Nifty 50; was −1.25).
  - CAPE version: −0.27 and −0.29 (were −0.26 and −0.26).
  - The old t-values (−1.6 to −2.6) were invalid. With 2 non-overlapping 10-year windows, the honest statement is the median and the non-overlapping means (−1.0 to −1.4).
- **S2, S4, S5:** unchanged.
- **FD proxy (L23), noted for the next revision:** the proxy accrues a floating T-bill yield, not the one-year locked rate this spec describes. It stays labelled “FD proxy” until lane 1’s deposit-rate series arrive.

2026-10-07, wording only: the site is run by one person, so “we” and “our” now read “I” and “my”. No definition, test, threshold or result changed.

This is `docs/research/sip_studies_spec.md`. The specification was committed before any result was computed; changes after that are logged in it with dates and reasons.

---

Historical research, not investment advice. This page in HTML: https://tipsheet.markets/research/sip_studies_spec/. Every published dataset: https://tipsheet.markets/data/v1/manifest.json. A map of the site: https://tipsheet.markets/llms.txt
