---
title: "An Indian model library: what I can learn from Allocate Smartly, and a proposal"
url: https://tipsheet.markets/research/model_library_proposal/
description: "Pre-registered research specification and results log: An Indian model library: what I can learn from Allocate Smartly, and a proposal."
updated: 2026-10-29
publisher: tipsheet (https://tipsheet.markets/)
cite: "tipsheet, “An Indian model library: what I can learn from Allocate Smartly, and a proposal”, 29 October 2026, https://tipsheet.markets/research/model_library_proposal/"
---

[Pre-registered research](https://tipsheet.markets/research/)

# An Indian model library: what I can learn from Allocate Smartly, and a proposal

Written 2026-10-03 for the model audit (`docs/briefs/model_audit.md`). This is a proposal for the owner’s decision, not a pre-registration. Each study in it still needs its own spec before anything is computed.

## What Allocate Smartly does (read from its public pages, 2026-10-03)

Allocate Smartly (allocatesmartly.com) replicates published tactical asset-allocation strategies for US investors. Its strategy pages, screener and “current allocation” views sit behind a members’ login. Everything below comes from the public pages cited, and where the public pages are silent I say so. Nothing here is copied text or design.

- **One standard footing.**
  
  - **Assets:** every strategy runs on one fixed set of 37 liquid ETFs. Before an ETF existed, the index it tracks is used, minus the expense ratio of a similar ETF. Academic factor series are rejected as unrealistic proxies. ([common assets](https://allocatesmartly.com/for-the-nerds-why-we-conform-all-strategies-to-a-common-set-of-assets/), [FAQ](https://allocatesmartly.com/faqs/), [unrealistic data](https://allocatesmartly.com/perils-backtesting-unrealistic-data/))
  - **Costs and cash:** 0.10% per trade. Trades at the close; monthly strategies trade on the last trading day of the month. Dividends are reinvested. Cash earns the 3-month T-bill rate. ([FAQ](https://allocatesmartly.com/faqs/))
  - **Execution lag:** they measured the cost of trading a day after the signal: about 0.28% a year for month-end signals. ([one-day lag](https://allocatesmartly.com/adding-a-1-day-lag-when-executing-taa-strategies/))
- **Comparison.**
  
  - **Metrics:** CAGR; current, maximum and longest drawdown (month-end basis); Sharpe; Sortino; the Ulcer performance index; turnover.
  - **Benchmark:** a 60/40 portfolio. ([FAQ](https://allocatesmartly.com/faqs/))
  - **Robustness:** every monthly strategy is rerun on each of 21 normalised trading days. Good results only at month-end are read as overfitting. ([alternate trading days](https://allocatesmartly.com/alternate-trading-days-important-analytical-tool/))
  - **Significance:** I found no formal significance testing on the public pages.
- **What each strategy holds today.**
  
  - Members see the expected allocation from the open, and get alerts when a change is likely that day.
  - A trade (a change in target) is kept separate from a rebalance (drift correction).
  - An aggregate of all strategies’ allocations is published daily. ([FAQ](https://allocatesmartly.com/faqs/), [aggregate allocation](https://allocatesmartly.com/the-wisdom-of-100-strategies-using-aggregate-taa-allocation-as-a-trading-signal/))
- **Blends.**
  
  - Members combine whole strategies into portfolios, rebalanced monthly with the same costs.
  - A blend’s history starts once 80% of its weight has data.
  - An optimiser exists, but its method is not published. ([FAQ](https://allocatesmartly.com/faqs/), [features](https://allocatesmartly.com/advanced-features/))
- **Timing luck.**
  
  - One strategy’s CAGR ranged from 9.6% to 16.2% depending on the day of the month it traded.
  - The remedy is tranching (the same strategy on several days) and blending. ([tranching](https://allocatesmartly.com/timing-luck-portfolio-tranching/))
- **Decay after publication.**
  
  - Not handled systematically on the public pages: the strategy list carries no publication dates. ([list](https://allocatesmartly.com/list-of-strategies/))
  - Individual articles comment on a strategy’s record after publication.
- **Honesty.**
  
  - A “things that don’t work” category.
  - No parameter tweaking by users (“a recipe for overfitting”).
  - Proprietary strategies need three years of verified out-of-sample record. ([FAQ](https://allocatesmartly.com/faqs/), [black boxes](https://allocatesmartly.com/super-secret-proprietary-black-box-strategies/))

## What tipsheet already does that this site does not (on its public pages)

- **Pre-registration:** written specs before results, and logs of every change.
- **Deflated Sharpe ratios** with trial counts.
- **After-tax results** under Indian rules by date.
- **Nulls published as findings.**

Allocate Smartly’s discipline is mostly in the plumbing: one asset set, one cost model, timing robustness by default. Mine is mostly in the inference. The proposal combines the two.

## Proposal: the tipsheet model library (India)

1. **One engine, one footing.**
   
   - **Engine:** every tactical model (trend rules, the trend ensemble, sector and index momentum, the lab’s rule-based portfolios) runs on `lab/engine.py`: lots, costs by date, tax by financial year, and trades at the next close after the signal.
   - **Fixed instrument set:** Nifty 50, Next 50, Midcap 150 and Smallcap 250 index funds; gold ETF; 5-year G-sec (until a long G-sec TRI arrives); liquid fund. Pre-launch history is the tracked index minus a real expense ratio, flagged on the chart.
2. **Every model carries three dates:**
   
   - its **source date** (when the rule was published, for example Faber 2007);
   - its **entry date** (when it entered my library: its spec commit);
   - its **data start**.
   - Charts shade three periods differently: before the source date (in-sample for the author), between the two dates (out of sample for the author, but seen by me), and after the entry date (truly out of sample for me).
   - A table gives the return after each date beside the full-history return. This is the McLean and Pontiff (2016) test, model by model.
3. **“What each model holds today” board.**
   
   - One row per model: today’s target, the date of the last change, and how close the signal is to switching.
   - A “changes likely at this month-end” flag on the last three sessions of the month.
   - An aggregate row: the average equity exposure across all models.
   - Descriptive only, beside each model’s verdict (a deflated Sharpe that passed or failed).
4. **Timing luck by default.** Every monthly model is shown with its spread across 21 trading-day offsets (the trend barometer already measures this) and as a tranched version. The headline number is the tranched one.
5. **Blends.**
   
   - Readers can combine library models with fixed weights; the blend is computed on the same engine, with tax.
   - No optimiser, and no parameter changes: the model list is the menu.
   - A blend starts only when all its models have data.
6. **A “didn’t survive” shelf.** Retired or failed models stay listed with the reason and the evidence (for example sector momentum v1: no edge over equal weight, deflated Sharpe 0.41).
7. **Live tracking.** From each entry date, the pipeline appends the model’s daily return to a frozen log that never recomputes. This gives a real out-of-sample record, separate from the backtest, which does get recomputed when data are repaired.

### First models to load (all pre-registered or published in the literature)

- Faber 10-month SMA; 200-day SMA; 12-month time-series momentum; the 1/3/6/12 blend; the 24-signal trend ensemble.
- Dual momentum: Nifty 50 against gold against cash (Antonacci 2014).
- A two-asset Indian adaptation of the permanent portfolio.
- 50:50 equity:gold with a 200-day trend filter on each sleeve.
- Valuation-glide rules from lab v2.

Each needs its own spec, with the Indian substitutions written down before it is run.

### What it needs from other lanes

- **Lane 1:** NSE index launch dates (to mark back-filled history); a long-duration G-sec TRI.
- **Lanes 3 and 4:** a three-period shaded chart, and a holdings board component.

2026-10-07, wording only: the site is run by one person, so “we” and “our” now read “I” and “my”. No definition, test, threshold or result changed.

This is `docs/research/model_library_proposal.md`. The specification was committed before any result was computed; changes after that are logged in it with dates and reasons.

---

Historical research, not investment advice. This page in HTML: https://tipsheet.markets/research/model_library_proposal/. Every published dataset: https://tipsheet.markets/data/v1/manifest.json. A map of the site: https://tipsheet.markets/llms.txt
