---
title: "Method: Valuation: P/E, CAPE, dividend yield and yield gaps"
url: https://tipsheet.markets/methods/valuation/
description: "How tipsheet.markets computes valuation: p/e, cape, dividend yield and yield gaps: sources, start dates, checks and caveats."
updated: 2026-10-29
publisher: tipsheet (https://tipsheet.markets/)
cite: "tipsheet, “Method: Valuation: P/E, CAPE, dividend yield and yield gaps”, 29 October 2026, https://tipsheet.markets/methods/valuation/"
---

[Methods](https://tipsheet.markets/methods/)

# Valuation: P/E, CAPE, dividend yield and yield gaps

**Code:** `pipeline/tipsheet/compute/valuation.py`, `publish/valuation.py`.

**Bundles:** `valuation/*`.

**Coverage:** 22 indices, listed in `CORE_INDICES`.

## Inputs

- **NSE daily P/E, P/B and dividend yield** (`nifty_index_valuations`). Nifty 50, Nifty 500 and Nifty IT go back to 1999. Others start at their launch.
- **Index levels:** price and total return, from NSE.
- **CPI:** India Data Hub `INCPBLCPIA12M`, the spliced CPI with 2012 = 100.
  
  - I checked it against MoSPI’s 2024-base series. The level ratio is constant from 2013 to 2026, and 2026 year-on-year rates match within 0.01 pp.
  - Of about 62 identical vintages, the latest is used.
- **10-year G-sec yield:** monthly, from India Data Hub.
- **Household inflation expectations:** 12 months ahead, from RBI’s survey via India Data Hub.

## CAPE

1. **Implied earnings per share:** close ÷ P/E.
2. **Real earnings:** each month’s EPS is restated in today’s rupees using CPI.
3. **CAPE:** today’s real price ÷ the average real EPS over the 120 complete months before this one. It needs 10 years of P/E history, so Nifty 50’s CAPE starts in 2009.

### NSE’s 2021 switch from standalone to consolidated earnings

- **What happened:** on **2021-03-31**, NSE moved index P/E from standalone to consolidated earnings. Nifty 50’s P/E fell from 40.4 to 33.2 in a day while the index moved about 1%.
- **The adjustment:** the factor is measured per index on that date, as consolidated EPS ÷ standalone EPS. Earlier EPS is scaled by it.
- **When the adjustment is withheld:**
  
  - The adjustment is trusted only if the factor lies between 0.85 and 1.35.
  - Outside that band, scaling ten years of history by one day’s ratio isn’t credible. So the adjusted CAPE is withheld, and only the unadjusted CAPE is published.
  - Examples: Auto 0.27, Metal 0.53, Realty 0.26, Midcap 100 2.17. Auto’s and Metal’s factors are below 1 because of real overseas-subsidiary losses.
- **What I publish:** both series, `cape` (consolidated basis) and `cape_unadjusted`.
- **P/B** shows no break at the 2021 switch, but has its own (next section).

## NSE’s 2023 P/B break

- **What happened:** on **2023-09-29** NSE’s P/B stepped down across indices with prices flat. Implied book value (close ÷ P/B) rose 25% for the Nifty 50, 19% for the Nifty 500 and 34% for Infrastructure, against 0.5% for the Midcap 100. No other Nifty 50 session since 2003 moves implied book by more than 7%. NSE has published no note; the pattern (largest for groups with big subsidiaries) is consistent with a move to consolidated book value.
- **The adjustment:** `pb_adjusted` scales book value before the break by each index’s ratio that day, exactly as the P/E switch is handled, with the same 0.85–1.35 band (every index is inside it). `pb_ratio` keeps NSE’s figure.
- **What it changed:** P/B percentiles now use `pb_adjusted`. Before this fix the page put the Nifty 50’s P/B at its 10th percentile; on one basis it is at its 43rd. D1’s P/B predictor moved to `pb_adjusted` too (logged in `audit_deepening_spec.md`).

### Check against IIMA

The comparison is with Jacob and Raju’s CAPE at IIM Ahmedabad, capeindia.iima.ac.in (cite: Jacob and Raju 2024, SSRN 4911989).

- **My unadjusted Nifty 500 CAPE matches theirs:**
  
  - correlation 0.995 over 212 months
  - median ratio 1.007
- **IIMA does not adjust for the 2021 switch.**
- **Where today sits:** on a consistent consolidated basis, Nifty 500’s CAPE in August 2026 was at the 85th percentile since 2009. IIMA’s series puts it at the 78th.
  
  - My adjustment assumes the consolidated/standalone gap was constant. If the gap was smaller in the 2000s, the early years are over-adjusted.
  - So the truth likely lies between the two. Both are published, with this explanation.

## Dividend yield

- **NSE changed its dividend-yield method on the same date** (2021-03-31). Persistent jumps appear that differ by index: FMCG 1.32 → 2.74%, Auto 1.66 → 0.57%.
- **The primary series is `dividend_yield_tri`:** the trailing 250-session yield implied by the gap between the total-return and price indices. It is computed one way throughout.
  
  - Over long periods it tracks NSE’s figure (median ratio 0.9–1.0).
- NSE’s own figure is kept alongside.

## Yield gaps

| Measure | Definition |
| --- | --- |
| Earnings yield | 100 ÷ P/E on the consolidated basis (since 2026-10-03; NSE’s raw figure is kept as `earnings_yield_nse_pct`, which steps up about 20% on 2021-03-31) |
| Nominal yield gap | Earnings yield − 10-year G-sec yield |
| Real yield gap | CAPE earnings yield (100 ÷ CAPE) − real 10-year G-sec yield |
| Real G-sec yield (CPI) | 10-year G-sec yield − CPI inflation, year on year |
| Real G-sec yield (survey) | 10-year G-sec yield − households’ 12-month inflation expectation |

## Percentiles

- The snapshot reports each measure’s percentile within its own history, with the date that history starts.
- P/E percentiles use the consolidated basis. Where the adjustment is withheld, they use only the history since the switch.
- P/B percentiles use `pb_adjusted` (one basis across the 2023 break).
- CAPE percentiles need at least 60 months of CAPE.

## Audit notes (2026-10-03)

- **The earnings yield and the yield gaps** now use the consolidated-basis P/E (register V3). Before this, they inherited NSE’s 2021 break, and so did C1, the lab’s yield-gap glide and the yield-gap dynamic SIP.
- **The valuation step** writes `valuation_nifty_50.parquet` and `valuation_nifty_500.parquet` at the top of the derived folder again (register V7). Other modules read those copies, and they had stopped updating on 2026-09-28.
- **CPI timing:** the historical CAPE deflates each day’s price by that month’s CPI, which is published around the 12th of the next month. The look-ahead is at most one month’s inflation on the level, and today’s value uses the last published CPI.
- **Valuation and later returns:** see D1 in `docs/research/audit_deepening_spec.md`. Starting valuation has gone with later returns, but no predictor passes once overlap, small-sample bias and out-of-sample testing are accounted for.

## Index return decomposition (2026-10-04)

**Code:** `compute/return_decomposition.py`; published with the valuation step. **Bundles:** `valuation/returns/<index>_monthly`, `valuation/returns_snapshot`.

For same-date positive price index P, published P/E M, and total-return index T, index-implied earnings E = P/M. Between two observations:

`100 × Δln(T) = 100 × Δln(E) + 100 × Δln(M) + 100 × Δln(T/P)`.

These are cumulative **log-return points**, not ordinary percentage-point shares. The ordinary return is `100 × (exp(total_log/100) − 1)` and is shown separately. The three components reconcile before rounding. No index levels are published.

- The chart samples trailing calendar-year windows monthly, retaining actual observation dates. The current month may be partial. The table also offers cumulative three- and five-year windows, without annualisation.
- The start is the last joint observation on or before the anniversary, no more than seven calendar days earlier. Missing, non-positive or non-finite endpoint values withhold the whole decomposition. Inputs never use independently selected dates.
- All windows crossing 31 March 2021 are withheld, even for indices whose CAPE splice is accepted. This decomposition uses raw published P/E within each earnings-method regime; it does not turn a one-day standalone/consolidated adjustment into observed profit growth.
- Index-implied earnings include changes in constituent membership, weights and NSE earnings definitions. They are not constant-company or organic earnings. T/P captures the dividend-reinvestment convention, not a cash dividend yield or a separately measured dividend contribution.
- This is a retrospective accounting identity, not causal attribution or a trading signal. It uses the current source vintage and does not claim point-in-time availability.

Company-level earnings attribution, constant-membership comparisons, and splits between margin, revenue, dilution and buybacks remain dependent on missing inputs listed in `docs/plans/DATA_REQUIREMENTS_2026-10-04.md` (DR01–DR04).

## Country equity risk premium (2026-10-05)

The valuation page reproduces Damodaran’s rating-based country ERP from his July 2026 workbook. Edition date: 1 July 2026; the workbook explicitly records default-spread corrections on 9 July. Retrieval is recorded separately. This corrected edition must not be treated as information available on 1 July in a backtest. No daily or historical ERP series is inferred from this snapshot.

ERP = mature-market ERP + rating-based default spread × equity/bond volatility multiplier. India: 4.20% + 1.7498812238% × 1.5544955263 ≈ 6.9202%. The published country component is approximately 2.7202%. The exact workbook multiplier and spread, rather than their rounded display values, drive all calculations. All 156 rows in the rating-based country table reconcile to cached source ERP and country-premium results within 0.001 percentage point. The US is excluded from this calculation universe because its ERP is estimated directly from market cash flows; its separate 4.42% benchmark is retained in the bundle. The separate PRS table for unrated countries is outside this implementation.

This premium measures country-adjusted required compensation above a default-free rate. It is not a Nifty-price-implied return, a yield gap, a rupee cost of equity, or a realised-return forecast. Company country exposure depends on operations rather than incorporation alone. No G-sec yield or restricted bond-yield transformation is published by this feature.

Source: [https://pages.stern.nyu.edu/~adamodar/pc/datasets/ctrypremJuly26.xlsx](https://pages.stern.nyu.edu/~adamodar/pc/datasets/ctrypremJuly26.xlsx) Method: [https://pages.stern.nyu.edu/~adamodar/New\_Home\_Page/datafile/ctryprem.html](https://pages.stern.nyu.edu/~adamodar/New_Home_Page/datafile/ctryprem.html) Captured workbook and provenance: `docs/reference/damodaran/`. The SHA-256 is verified before extraction. Excel cached results, shared strings, table headers and the workbook’s 1904 date epoch are respected. Computation performs no network fetch. To update, capture the author’s next dated workbook unchanged, record its URL, retrieval time and SHA in `latest.json`, and run the `country_erp` step. The parser rejects disabled adjustments, changed table headers, bad checksums, invalid inputs and unreconciled results. Preserve earlier captures and source correction notes; do not mix vintages.

## Depth chapters (2026-10-22)

**Code:** `compute/valuation_insights.py`, `publish/valuation_insights.py`, step `valuation_insights` (`steps/valuation_zz_insights.py`). **Bundles:** `valuation/size_spread_monthly`, `valuation/sector_dispersion_monthly`, `valuation/mcap_gdp_monthly`, `valuation/depth`.

- **Mid and small caps against large.** Month-end `pb_adjusted` of the Midcap 100 (from July 2005), Smallcap 100 (March 2011) and Next 50 (1999) over the Nifty 50’s. The P/E ratio is shown only from March 2021: before the switch the Midcap 100’s factor (2.17) can’t be bridged, so a longer P/E comparison would mix bases. P/B ÷ P/E is earnings per rupee of book, which explains why the two ratios disagree. The Smallcap 100’s P/B has source gaps (June 2016 to January 2017, February to May 2020); the lines break there.
- **Sector dispersion.** Ten sector indices (Bank, IT, FMCG, Pharma, Energy, Metal, Auto, Realty, Infrastructure, PSU Bank; Financial Services left out as a near-copy of Bank). Each month, each sector’s P/B percentile within its own month-end history up to then (point in time, at least 36 months); the interquartile range across sectors, from the first month with six eligible sectors (July 2010). All inputs are from after each index’s launch, so nothing is back-calculated.
- **Market value to GDP.** NSE month-end market value over the previous complete financial year’s nominal GDP (`density_mcap_gdp`, latest GDP vintage; in April and May the year’s provisional estimate is not yet out, a small look-ahead on the level). The second series is its percentage gap from its trailing 120-month average, which removes the slow rise from listings.
- **Long-run attribution.** Whole-history endpoint attribution on the consolidated basis, annualised in log points a year, for indices whose 2021 splice is trusted and with at least 15 years. The splice assumes the standalone-to-consolidated gap was constant; `valuation_unadjusted_ann` is the P/E term on NSE’s raw figures at both ends, and the gap between the two is the splice’s whole effect. Starting P/Es near a trough (Bank 2003, Next 50 2002) inflate the P/E term.
- **Tests (pre-registered, `site_calculations_spec.md`):** C20 (Midcap 100 relative P/B against its 3-year return over the Nifty 50, D1’s machinery), C21 (cheap minus dear sectors over 12 months, placebo), C22 (market value to GDP against 5-year real returns). None passes; results and grading in the spec’s results log.

## Valuation and later returns on the page

The page’s test is D1 (`audit_deepening_spec.md`): Hodrick errors, a bootstrap that keeps the Stambaugh bias, and out-of-sample R², on four measures at three horizons. The “at today’s valuation” line is D1’s fitted 5-year real return at the latest Sensex CAPE with its 80% interval, shown only while CAPE’s 5-year OOS R² is positive. C1’s tercile medians (with D2’s 90% intervals and independent periods) are kept as description; C1’s Newey-West table, which D1 superseded, is no longer shown.

**Overlap rule for every forward-return figure on the page (2026-10-22).** No chart or sentence treats overlapping windows as separate observations.

- The CAPE scatter plots only start months five years apart (the set from the first month, May 2000: five points), not all 257 overlapping months, whose R² of 0.69 is shown only as the illusion it is. A histogram gives the same fit on each of the 60 possible non-overlapping sets (4 or 5 periods each); their spread shows how much the answer depends on the start month. The sets share periods, so their share of negative slopes is not used as evidence (D1’s rule).
- The sector chart (C21) keeps its bar per start month but says to count independent years, not bars, and gives the one-start-a-year view: the win rate and mean gap for each of the 12 calendar start months.
- Every table of fitted effects shows independent periods, and its out-of-sample R² shows the independent periods it rests on.
- A claim that the CAPE line had flattened since 2010 was removed: it compared R² on overlapping months over about three independent periods, chosen after seeing the data.

## Earnings and GDP

**Code:** `compute/eps_gdp.py`, step `eps_gdp`. **Bundle:** `valuation/eps_gdp/yearly`. **Page:** `/valuation/#returns`.

- Nifty 50 EPS (close ÷ P/E) at the end of each March, on the consolidated basis with NSE’s April 2021 switch bridged (the same `eps` series as the rest of this page). It is set against MoSPI’s nominal GDP growth for the same financial year, each year taken from the newest base it appears in.
- **Result:** FY2000 to FY2026, EPS grew 11.0% a year and nominal GDP 11.7%. By stretch: FY2000–FY2008 17.7% against 11.9%; FY2008–FY2020 5.6% against 12.5%; FY2020–FY2026 13.4% against 10.0%. Yearly growth rates correlate 0.54.
- **Limits:** index earnings change when members change, so this is not one fixed set of companies. FY2021 growth depends on the bridge (−17.2% bridged, −0.3% on NSE’s raw figures). GDP base years are spliced.

This note is the repository file `docs/methods/valuation.md`, rendered as-is.

---

Historical research, not investment advice. This page in HTML: https://tipsheet.markets/methods/valuation/. Every published dataset: https://tipsheet.markets/data/v1/manifest.json. A map of the site: https://tipsheet.markets/llms.txt
